Setting up a business in France from abroad starts with one decision that shapes everything else: the legal vehicle. A foreign founder typically hesitates between three routes — creating a simplified joint-stock company (SAS, société par actions simplifiée), creating a limited liability company (SARL, société à responsabilité limitée), or operating through a branch (succursale) of the existing foreign company. Each route gives the shareholder limited liability, but they differ profoundly on who decides what, how shares or interests change hands, which social regime covers the director, how profits are taxed, and what must be filed every year. Choosing badly means paying twice: once to set up, once to convert, as our guide on converting a French branch into an SAS subsidiary illustrates. This guide explains, entirely from French statutes and court decisions read for this article, how the three vehicles compare at creation and in operation, so that a non-resident founder can sign the right statutes, fund the company, register it through the single online gateway, and run the annual legal calendar from abroad with full knowledge of the consequences.
I. Should You Create an SAS, an SARL or Open a Branch in France?
The question looks administrative. It is in fact strategic: the vehicle determines who can bind the company, who can enter or leave, and who answers for the debts. A subsidiary (SAS, SARL or single-shareholder SASU) is a French legal person distinct from its foreign parent; a branch is not — it is the foreign company acting in France under a registered establishment.
A. SAS or SARL: what changes for a foreign shareholder at creation?
Both the SAS and the SARL give their members the same foundational protection: the statutes express it in nearly identical words. Under Article L227-1 of the Commercial Code, “Une société par actions simplifiée peut être instituée par une ou plusieurs personnes qui ne supportent les pertes qu’à concurrence de leur apport”, and under Article L223-1 of the Commercial Code, “La société à responsabilité limitée est instituée par une ou plusieurs personnes qui ne supportent les pertes qu’à concurrence de leurs apports”. In both cases, a single person can form the company alone — the single-shareholder SAS (SASU) or the single-shareholder SARL (EURL) — and exercises alone the powers of the shareholders. The real differences lie elsewhere: in contractual freedom, in governance, and in transferability.
The SAS is the vehicle of contractual freedom. Article L227-5 of the Commercial Code states, in one sentence that explains the success of the form with foreign investors: “Les statuts fixent les conditions dans lesquelles la société est dirigée.” The founders write their own governance — voting rights, vetoes, qualified majorities, exclusion clauses, share-transfer restrictions — subject only to a short list of decisions that the law reserves to the shareholders collectively. The SARL, by contrast, is a statutory company: the Commercial Code fixes the majority rules, the approval (agrément) procedure for transfers to third parties, and the powers of the manager (gérant), leaving the statutes a narrower, though real, margin. A foreign group that wants bespoke governance — disproportionate voting rights, an investor director with a veto, a leaver mechanism for a local partner — will therefore almost always prefer the SAS. A family business or a wholly owned operating subsidiary with simple governance can live perfectly well in a SARL, whose framework is protective and predictable.
Representation toward third parties follows the same contrast. Every SAS has a president (président) appointed as the statutes provide, and Article L227-6 of the Commercial Code provides that “La société est représentée à l’égard des tiers par un président désigné dans les conditions prévues par les statuts. Le président est investi des pouvoirs les plus étendus pour agir en toute circonstance au nom de la société dans la limite de l’objet social.” The same article adds that, in dealings with third parties, the company is bound even by acts of the president outside the corporate purpose unless it proves the third party knew or should have known: “Dans les rapports avec les tiers, la société est engagée même par les actes du président qui ne relèvent pas de l’objet social, à moins qu’elle ne prouve que le tiers savait que l’acte dépassait cet objet ou qu’il ne pouvait l’ignorer compte tenu des circonstances”. The statutes may also create general managers (directeurs généraux) with the same representative power. In an SARL, only the manager represents the company, within a similar framework. For a foreign founder, the practical lesson is identical in both forms: whoever is registered as president or manager can commit the company vis-à-vis banks, suppliers and the administration, and internal limits written into the statutes are unenforceable against a good-faith third party. Choose the representative carefully, verify the delegation chain, and register changes immediately.
Shareholder decisions also obey different logics. In the SAS, Article L227-9 of the Commercial Code provides that “Les statuts déterminent les décisions qui doivent être prises collectivement par les associés dans les formes et conditions qu’ils prévoient”, while reserving to the shareholders, acting collectively as the statutes organise, the powers that general meetings hold in public limited companies over capital increases, mergers, dissolution, transformation, statutory auditors, annual accounts and profits. In the SARL, the Code imposes the majority directly: under Article L223-29 of the Commercial Code, “les décisions sont adoptées par un ou plusieurs associés représentant plus de la moitié des parts sociales”, with a second consultation at a majority of votes cast if the first fails, unless the statutes say otherwise. A foreign parent holding 60% of an SARL therefore controls ordinary decisions but must still compose with the statutory framework for transfers and for special majorities; in an SAS, the same 60% can mean whatever the statutes negotiated at incorporation say it means — control, or minority protection, depending on drafting.
Transfers of interests are where the SARL shows its closed character. Article L223-14 of the Commercial Code lays down the default rule: “Les parts sociales ne peuvent être cédées à des tiers étrangers à la société qu’avec le consentement de la majorité des associés représentant au moins la moitié des parts sociales”. The draft transfer is notified to the company and to each shareholder, and the same article attaches a strict time limit with a clear starting point: “Si la société n’a pas fait connaître sa décision dans le délai de trois mois à compter de la dernière des notifications prévues au présent alinéa, le consentement à la cession est réputé acquis.” If approval is refused, the shareholders must, within three months of that refusal, acquire or procure the acquisition of the shares at a price fixed under Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code, unless the seller withdraws. For a foreign investor who may later sell to an outside buyer or bring in a co-investor, this approval mechanism is a feature when it protects the group and a trap when it blocks an exit; it must be anticipated in a shareholders’ agreement. In an SAS, transfer restrictions exist only if the statutes create them — approval clauses, pre-emption, inalienability for up to ten years — and our analysis of selling or transferring shares of a French company from abroad details how price and approval disputes are handled in practice.
Two judgments of the Commercial Chamber of the Court of Cassation, both read in full for this article, show why SAS statutes deserve the founder’s closest attention — particularly the clauses on removing a director. In a decision of 9 March 2022 (pourvoi no. 19-25.795, official decision), the Court approved an appeal ruling with the principle that “les conditions dans lesquelles les dirigeants d’une société par actions simplifiée peuvent être révoqués de leurs fonctions sont, dans le silence de la loi, librement fixées par les statuts, qu’il s’agisse des causes de la révocation ou de ses modalités”, and concluded that “c’est à bon droit que l’arrêt décide que la révocation de M. [N] en tant que directeur général de la société Hubbard pouvait intervenir sans qu’il soit nécessaire de justifier d’un juste motif.” A clause providing that managers “sont révocables à tout moment” therefore means exactly what it says: removal without cause, without compensation, unless the statutes grant one. Symmetrically, in a decision of 12 October 2022 (pourvoi no. 21-15.382, official decision), the Court held that “Il résulte de la combinaison des articles L. 227-1 et L. 227-5 du code de commerce que les statuts de la société par actions simplifiée fixent les conditions dans lesquelles la société est dirigée, notamment les modalités de révocation de son directeur général. Si les actes extra-statutaires peuvent compléter ces statuts, ils ne peuvent y déroger.” An appointment letter promising an indemnity could not override statutes excluding any indemnity. For a foreign founder, the message is blunt: in an SAS, the statutes are the constitution — side letters complete them but never contradict them — so every protection for the investor-director or the local manager (notice, cause, severance, non-compete) must be written into the statutes themselves or into an agreement that the statutes expressly allow.
Formation formalities are now common to both forms and fully online. Since the reform of business formalities, Article L123-33 of the Commercial Code requires that “toute entreprise se conforme à l’obligation de déclarer sa création, la modification de sa situation ou la cessation de ses activités auprès d’une administration, d’une personne ou d’un organisme mentionnés à l’article L. 123-32 par le dépôt d’un seul dossier comportant les déclarations qu’elle est tenue d’effectuer”, filed electronically with the single body — in practice the Guichet unique operated with the National Institute of Industrial Property (INPI, Institut national de la propriété industrielle). Capital is deposited with a bank, which issues the deposit certificate; then, once registered, the company exists as a person. Under Article L210-6 of the Commercial Code, “Les sociétés commerciales jouissent de la personnalité morale à dater de leur immatriculation au registre du commerce et des sociétés”, and acts done beforehand in the company’s name bind those who acted, unless the company takes them over after registration. The registration certificate — the Kbis extract (extrait Kbis), issued by the greffe, the clerk’s office of the commercial court — is the identity card the bank, the notary and suppliers will demand. Foreign founders who hit a bank refusal at the deposit or account stage will find the remedies, including the right-to-an-account procedure (droit au compte), in our companion guides on opening a company account when the bank says no and the earlier account-refusal analysis.
B. Branch or subsidiary: when the French presence is not a company at all
A branch (succursale) is seductive: no share capital to incorporate, no French statutes to draft, a lighter file. But it is not a company. It has no legal personality distinct from the foreign head office, no Kbis of its own in the same sense as a subsidiary (it is registered as an establishment of a foreign company), and above all no liability shield between Paris and the head office: creditors of the French activity can pursue the foreign company’s assets, and French proceedings can reach decisions whose enforcement crosses borders. A subsidiary confines the risk to the capital contributed; a branch exposes the whole group. For testing the market with two salespeople and a serviced office, that exposure may be acceptable; for signing a 3/6/9 commercial lease (bail commercial), hiring staff, or taking on French debt, it rarely is — and landlords and banks know it, which is why they often ask the foreign parent for guarantees that erase the apparent simplicity. Our lease guide for foreign companies on signing a 3/6/9 commercial lease from abroad shows how landlords secure themselves when the tenant’s substance sits overseas.
Tax follows substance, not labels. A branch that habitually carries on business in France is taxed in France on its French profits: under Article 206 of the General Tax Code, companies limited by shares and limited liability companies are liable to corporate income tax regardless of purpose, and foreign companies operating an establishment in France fall within French corporate tax on the profits attributable to that establishment, with VAT obligations for their French transactions as analysed in our VAT registration and returns guide. A branch therefore saves no tax by itself; it merely avoids the formalities of a subsidiary while importing unlimited liability, thinner governance (no French board, no local decision record), and recurring practical friction — every French counterparty will ask for head-office documents, apostilled, translated, and re-explained. A subsidiary, once registered, speaks French administratively: Kbis, French tax number, French VAT number, French payroll.
The registration path reflects that difference. A subsidiary files one incorporation dossier through the Guichet unique and emerges with full registration; a branch registers the foreign company as operating an establishment in France, disclosing head-office details, the French address, and the person empowered to act locally. Regulated activities — finance, health, private security, temporary work, among others — may require prior authorisation regardless of form, and acquisitions in sensitive sectors by foreign investors can trigger the foreign-investment screening (autorisation d’investissement étranger, IEF) described in our IEF approval guide. Founders based in Paris and the Île-de-France region register with the Paris commercial court registry, whose practical routines — electronic filing, document checks, issuance of the Kbis — are the same as elsewhere in France, with the capital’s advantage being proximity to banks’ international desks, translators and counsel rather than any separate legal regime.
Conversion remains possible but is never costless, which is why the initial choice matters. A branch can later be transformed into an SAS subsidiary, the contracts and staff transferred, and the branch struck off — the full sequence, with its tax and employment traps, is set out step by step in our branch-to-SAS conversion guide. Founders who already know they will hire, borrow or sign long leases in France within twelve months generally save money by incorporating the subsidiary immediately rather than paying for a branch now and a conversion later.
II. What Does Each Vehicle Cost and Pay Once It Operates?
Creation costs are a one-off; operating costs recur every month and every year. The vehicle drives three of them directly: the director’s social status, the taxation of profits, and the weight of annual filings. A founder living abroad must price all three before choosing, because the cheapest company to incorporate is not always the cheapest to run.
A. Who runs the company and which social regime applies to the director?
French social law classifies directors not by their title but by their mandate, and the classification decides the monthly bill. The president of an SAS — and any general manager the statutes create — belongs to the general social security scheme as an assimilated employee (assimilé salarié): contributions are levied on actual remuneration, with no minimum while unpaid, and the director accrues employee-regime protection without unemployment insurance. The statute says it directly: Article L311-3 of the Social Security Code includes among compulsorily affiliated persons “Les présidents et dirigeants des sociétés par actions simplifiées et des sociétés d’exercice libéral par actions simplifiées”. An unpaid SAS president therefore costs the company nothing in social charges — a decisive advantage for a foreign founder who draws income from the head office and keeps the French mandate unpaid. Our dedicated analysis of the SAS president’s social status and cost from abroad prices each scenario, including the resident director who does take a salary.
The SARL manager (gérant) follows a split rule built on shareholding. The same Article L311-3 of the Social Security Code affiliates only minority or equal managers to the general scheme: “Les gérants de sociétés à responsabilité limitée et de sociétés d’exercice libéral à responsabilité limitée à condition que lesdits gérants ne possèdent pas ensemble plus de la moitié du capital social”, counting the shares of spouse, civil partner and minor children as the manager’s own. A majority manager falls instead under the self-employed scheme, with contributions on professional income including minimum bases even in lean years, and a different pension and daily-allowance architecture. For a foreign founder holding 100% of an EURL and acting as manager, that means the independent scheme with its fixed floor; the same founder chairing a SASU with no salary pays no French social charges on the mandate. The difference, compounded over years, often outweighs the notary or filing fees that attracted the founder to one form in the first place.
Beyond cost, removal and liability regimes diverge exactly as the statutes suggest. The SAS president or general manager is removed as the statutes provide — with or without cause, with or without indemnity — under the case law quoted above; drafting the clause at incorporation is the only moment it is cheap. The SARL manager is removed by shareholders representing more than half the shares and can claim damages if removed without cause, unless the manager is also a shareholder whose removal follows the statutory framework. Criminal and civil liability for mismanagement (faute de gestion), late filing for insolvency proceedings, and tax fraud attach to the de facto as well as the de jure director in both forms, residence abroad being no shield once the person directs from Paris or from a laptop. A non-resident director should therefore keep written delegation records, board or shareholder minutes, and a French address for service, and should understand that French courts will look at who actually decided, not at the title on the Kbis.
The first hire adds the second recurring cost block, administered by URSSAF (Unions de recouvrement des cotisations de sécurité sociale et d’allocations familiales), the body that collects social contributions. Whoever the employer — SAS, SARL or branch — the pre-hiring declaration (DPAE, déclaration préalable à l’embauche), the written contract, working-time recording for the 35-hour week, and payslip discipline are identical, and the overtime guide for first employees’ overtime while the founder lives abroad and the URSSAF-audit guide on controls, assessments and challenges from abroad apply to all three vehicles equally. The vehicle changes only who signs the employment contract for the company and which director answers to the labour court (conseil de prud’hommes) if the relationship breaks down — another reason to align governance clauses with HR reality from day one.
B. Corporate tax, VAT and the annual filings you must not miss
Once registered, the French vehicle enters two tax houses simultaneously: corporate income tax on its profits and VAT on its transactions. Corporate income tax (impôt sur les sociétés) applies to SAS and SARL companies by status: Article 206 of the General Tax Code makes liable, whatever their purpose, joint-stock companies, partnerships limited by shares and “les sociétés à responsabilité limitée”, subject only to the narrow partnerships-regime option the article reserves. The standard rate is set by Article 219 of the General Tax Code: “Le taux normal de l’impôt est fixé à 25 %.” Branches are taxed on the profits attributable to the French establishment under the same rate. Our corporate-tax guide for foreign companies on rate, instalments, returns and corrections from abroad details how instalments and balances work in practice, and the dividend guide on repatriating dividends, withholding and treaty refunds covers the exit side — withholding, treaty relief and the refund procedure when the treaty rate beats the domestic levy. A founder choosing between distributing, reinvoicing management fees, or capitalising a shareholder loan should read those two guides together with the shareholder-loan analysis on current-account funding, repayment and tax, because each channel carries its own documentation and transfer-pricing discipline.
VAT (taxe sur la valeur ajoutée) follows activity, not form: any vehicle making taxable supplies in France registers, charges, recovers and files as our VAT registration and returns guide explains, and distance sellers and e-invoicing obligations now add a digital layer analysed in the e-invoicing obligation guide. The practical trap for newcomers is not the rate but the chain: obtaining the VAT number late blocks recovery, filing late triggers penalties automatically, and correcting through the wrong channel compounds the error. A subsidiary obtains its numbers in the incorporation flow; a branch must request them for the establishment — in both cases through filings the founder can sign from abroad with electronic identification.
The annual legal calendar then takes over and never stops. Accounts must be approved, filed with the greffe, and published or kept confidential as the size thresholds allow; the meeting or written consultation, the management report, and the filing receipts form the paper trail that banks, buyers and courts will demand years later. The full timetable, with late-filing fixes, is laid out in our annual legal-calendar guide, and the official company gazette — BODACC (Bulletin officiel des annonces civiles et commerciales), where creations, transfers of business and insolvency openings are published — is the public mirror the founder should check after each filing. Branches file the head-office accounts locally under conditions that vary with the head office’s home state, another recurring friction that subsidiaries avoid. Add the territorial economic contribution (CET, contribution économique territoriale), the payroll and social declarations (DSN, déclaration sociale nominative), and sectoral licences where applicable, and the founder sees the true comparison: the SAS costs slightly more in drafting, the SARL slightly more in rigidity, the branch slightly less at entry and steadily more every year after.
Conclusion
A foreign founder who wants control, tailored governance and a director mandate that can stay unpaid while the business ramps up will, in most cases, incorporate an SAS — usually a SASU at the start — and write investor-grade statutes once, at incorporation. A founder who prefers a protective statutory frame, a family-scale capital lock through the approval procedure, and a manager-led operation will find the SARL, or the EURL, perfectly serviceable. A branch earns its place only as a light, temporary beachhead: as soon as the French presence hires, borrows, leases or invoices at scale, the subsidiary’s liability shield, French administrative identity and cleaner tax file outweigh the branch’s entry savings — and converting later always costs more than choosing well now. In all three cases the method is the same: draft the powers and the exit before the entry, deposit and register through the single gateway, verify the Kbis, open the tax and social accounts, and diary the annual approvals and filings from the first year.
Read also
- Your French Bank Said No and You Live Abroad: Deposit Capital, Register Your SAS or SARL and Force the Account Open
- Selling Your Shares in Your French Company While Living Abroad: Approval, Price, Duties and Filing for SARL and SAS Transfers
- Your French SAS Has a President Living Abroad: Social Security Status, Real Cost, Pay vs Dividends and Moving to France