Since Brexit, British citizens living in France are third-country nationals. The Withdrawal Agreement protected those who were already settled, but it gave them residence, not citizenship. For the growing number of Britons who now see their long-term future on the French side of the Channel — retirees in the Dordogne, seconded staff in Paris, remote workers in Lyon — one question keeps coming back: how do I become French, and what happens if the administration says no?
French law offers several routes to nationality. This article deals with only one of them: naturalisation by decree (naturalisation par décret), the discretionary route by which the French government may grant citizenship to a foreigner who asks for it. It is the route most settled Britons will use, because it does not depend on marrying a French citizen. Readers in that different situation should know that marriage to a French citizen follows a different declaration route, with its own conditions and its own opposition procedure.
Three warnings shape everything that follows. First, naturalisation by decree is a favour, not a right: even when every legal condition is met, the minister can still refuse, and the courts give the administration what the Conseil d’État calls a wide margin of appreciation. Second, the bar has risen: since 1 January 2026 the French page that lists the language proofs requires written as well as spoken French at level B2, a level many long-settled Britons who speak conversational French do not yet hold on paper. Third, refusals can be challenged — and the challenge often works when it targets the right defect, as a very recent ruling of the administrative court of appeal of Nantes, handed down on 13 October 2026, illustrates. This article explains the five-year residence rule, the language and character conditions, the assimilation interview, and the exact remedies against each type of unfavourable decision, with the legal texts quoted word for word.
I. Do you qualify for naturalisation by decree after Brexit?
Eligibility turns on three pillars: five years of habitual residence in France, genuine assimilation to the French community, and good character. Fail any one of them and the file stops. Meet all three and you are merely admissible — the minister still decides whether granting French nationality to you serves a useful purpose. Understanding each pillar before you apply saves years.
A. Have you lived in France continuously for five years — and will you still live here on signing day?
The central rule is stated in one sentence of the Civil Code: “Sous réserve des exceptions prévues aux articles 21-18 , 21-19 et 21-20 , la naturalisation ne peut être accordée qu’à l’étranger justifiant d’une résidence habituelle en France pendant les cinq années qui précèdent le dépôt de la demande.” (article 21-17 of the Civil Code). Five years of habitual residence (résidence habituelle) immediately before the application — that is the stage, as lawyers call it.
Habitual residence means more than a postal address. It means the centre of your settled life is in France: your home, your tax household, your daily activity, your family life. For Britons, two practical points matter most. First, long or repeated absences in the United Kingdom weaken the file, because they suggest the centre of life is still across the Channel; keep boarding passes, work calendars and school certificates that show France remained home. Second, keep your residence paperwork flawless throughout: an expired permit or a gap between two cards gives the administration an easy reason to doubt continuity. Holders of a Withdrawal Agreement card should read our guide to renewing the Withdrawal Agreement residence permit before any nationality step, because a residence problem poisons the nationality file that follows.
The five-year clock is not the only time condition. A second sentence is just as strict and often forgotten: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’a en France sa résidence au moment de la signature du décret de naturalisation.” (article 21-16 of the Civil Code). If you move back to Britain while the file is being examined — for a job, a family emergency, a house sale that drags on — and you are no longer resident in France when the decree is signed, you cannot be naturalised, however strong the rest of the file. Plan any return to the United Kingdom around this rule, not around convenience.
A minority of applicants qualify faster. The five-year stage is cut to two years for a foreigner who has completed two years of higher education leading to a French university degree: “Le stage mentionné à l’article 21-17 est réduit à deux ans : 1° Pour l’étranger qui a accompli avec succès deux années d’études supérieures en vue d’acquérir un diplôme délivré par une université ou un établissement d’enseignement supérieur français” (article 21-18 of the Civil Code). A British student who did a two-year master’s in France and stayed on therefore applies after two years, not five. Refugees, soldiers who served in the French army, and a handful of other cases can be naturalised with no stage at all under article 21-19, but those exceptions concern few British readers. The key voluntary step for everyone else remains article 21-15: “l’acquisition de la nationalité française par décision de l’autorité publique résulte d’une naturalisation accordée par décret à la demande de l’étranger” (article 21-15 of the Civil Code) — it is your written application that starts everything.
B. Can you prove B2 French and a clean record?
Assimilation (assimilation à la communauté française) is the condition that fails most British files. The Civil Code states it bluntly: “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il ne justifie de son assimilation à la communauté française, notamment par une connaissance suffisante, selon sa condition, de la langue, de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises, dont le niveau et les modalités d’évaluation sont fixés par décret en Conseil d’Etat, et des droits et devoirs conférés par la nationalité française ainsi que par l’adhésion aux principes et aux valeurs essentiels de la République.” (article 21-24 of the Civil Code). Language, history, culture, civic rights and duties, republican values — the check covers all of them, and the same article adds a language floor in demanding terms: “L’intéressé justifie d’un niveau de langue lui permettant au moins de comprendre le contenu essentiel de sujets concrets ou abstraits dans un texte complexe, de communiquer avec spontanéité, de s’exprimer de façon claire et détaillée sur une grande variété de sujets.”
In practice, the level currently demanded is B2 of the Common European Framework, in speaking and in writing. The official service-public.fr information page, verified on 1 January 2026, states that applicants must show knowledge of French at least equal to level B2, both oral and written (service-public.fr, proving your level of French). This is the single hardest novelty for many Britons: fifteen years of market-day French will not produce a B2 certificate. Accepted proofs include French state diplomas such as the brevet, certain vocational certificates, any diploma certifying B2 or above, and a pass certificate from an approved language test such as the TCF. Two dispensations exist — one for applicants from francophone backgrounds who meet three cumulative conditions, and one where a disability or health condition makes language assessment impossible — but a British applicant schooled in English in the United Kingdom should assume no dispensation and book the test early, because test places and results take months.
Language is only half of assimilation. The interview also probes history, culture and civic knowledge: the great markers of French history, republican principles and symbols, equality between men and women, secularism (laïcité), and the main lines of French political and administrative organisation. At the end of the examination the applicant signs the charter of the rights and duties of the French citizen (charte des droits et devoirs du citoyen français), which restates the essential principles, values and symbols of the Republic. Preparation should be concrete — dates, institutions, how the President is elected, what Parliament does — because, as the October 2026 Nantes ruling examined below shows, wrong answers on basic questions are enough to justify a two-year postponement even for an applicant with a permanent job and fluent spoken French.
Good character (bonnes vie et mœurs) is the third pillar, and criminal history the fastest way to lose a file. “Nul ne peut être naturalisé s’il n’est pas de bonnes vie et moeurs ou s’il a fait l’objet de l’une des condamnations visées à l’article 21-27 du présent code.” (article 21-23 of the Civil Code). Article 21-27 then lists automatic bars: convictions for crimes or offences against the fundamental interests of the Nation or acts of terrorism, and — whatever the offence — any sentence of six months’ imprisonment or more without suspension: “s’il a été condamné à une peine égale ou supérieure à six mois d’emprisonnement, non assortie d’une mesure de sursis” (article 21-27 of the Civil Code). The same article bars anyone under an unlifted expulsion order, anyone still under a French entry ban, and anyone whose stay in France is irregular: “Il en est de même de celui dont le séjour en France est irrégulier au regard des lois et conventions relatives au séjour des étrangers en France.” A British applicant living in France without a valid residence document need not even consider naturalisation until that is fixed.
Two nuances deserve attention. First, old British convictions are not automatically fatal: “Les condamnations prononcées à l’étranger pourront toutefois ne pas être prises en considération ; en ce cas, le décret prononçant la naturalisation ne pourra être pris qu’après avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat.” (article 21-23 of the Civil Code). Declare them honestly — concealment is far worse — and let the administration assess them. Second, financial conduct counts as character in the broad sense used by the ministry: unpaid rent, tax arrears and undeclared work all feed the assessment of integration and reliability, as the case law below confirms. A British landlord-tenant dispute or a forgotten tax bill will not always sink a file, but an applicant with debts should arrive with proof of repayment plans kept, not promises.
II. How the administration decides — and how to challenge a refusal
Once the file is lodged, the procedure belongs to the administration: inquiries, a personal interview, and a ministerial decision that can be favourable, unfavourable in three different ways, or simply late. Each outcome has its own remedy, its own time limit and its own court. This is where British applicants most often lose winnable cases — by missing a two-month deadline or by attacking the wrong defect.
A. What happens after you apply: the file, the interview and the 18-month clock
Applications are now lodged online, with the supporting documents listed by the administration, including the language diploma or test certificate, civil-status records with sworn translations, and proof of residence and resources (service-public.fr, naturalisation by decree). After registration you receive a ministerial file number, and later a receipt (récépissé) once the file is deemed complete enough to examine. From that moment, tell the administration everything that changes — address, marriage, divorce, new child, new job, period of unemployment — through your online personal space. Files are regularly damaged by changes the applicant forgot to declare and the administration discovered itself.
The heart of the examination is the individual assimilation interview at the prefecture (or, in Paris, the competent service), held after the inquiries into your conduct and loyalty. The decree governing the procedure provides that during a personal interview, and after receiving the inquiries, the officer checks the applicant’s assimilation against the criteria of article 21-24 and draws up a report of the interview. The court of appeal of Nantes quoted this mechanism word for word in October 2026: “Lors d’un entretien individuel et après réception des enquêtes prévues à l’article 36, l’agent vérifie l’assimilation du demandeur à la communauté française, selon les critères prévus par l’article 21-24 du code civil et établit un compte rendu de l’entretien.” (CAA Nantes, 3rd chamber, 13 October 2026, no. 25NT02098, full decision on Légifrance). The same ruling recalls what the interview must cover: “2° Le demandeur doit justifier d’un niveau de connaissance de l’histoire, de la culture et de la société françaises correspondant aux éléments fondamentaux” — the great markers of French history, republican principles, symbols and institutions, the rules of life in society including equality between men and women and secularism, and the main elements of French political and administrative organisation. The written report of this interview becomes the decisive piece of evidence if you later challenge a refusal, so what is said in that room matters more than anything else in the file. If you do not attend without a genuine reason, the application can be closed without examination (classement sans suite), and that closure itself states the remedies against it.
For applicants in Paris and the Île-de-France, the practicalities are the same but the logistics are heavier: file online early, expect the interview summons at short notice, and keep every payslip, tax notice (avis d’imposition) and rent receipt for the five-year period in one folder, because the Paris services systematically ask for top-up documents with short deadlines. If the examining service sets you a deadline to supply extra documents or complete a formality and you miss it, the file can be closed without examination, and the closure decision is notified with its remedies (service-public.fr, naturalisation by decree).
The administration’s time to answer runs from the récépissé: eighteen months at most, reduced to twelve months if you already show ten years of habitual residence in France on the date the receipt is issued, with one possible three-month extension that must be reasoned (service-public.fr, naturalisation by decree). Do not confuse this examination period with acceptance: no news within eighteen months is not a nationality certificate. If the outcome is favourable, you are informed of your entry in the naturalisation decree after publication in the Journal officiel, and the decree takes effect on the date it is signed. Your unmarried minor children who habitually live with you also become French if their names appear in the decree, with minority assessed on the signing date — a detail that matters for British families with teenagers approaching eighteen. The decree can later be withdrawn within two years of publication on the conforming opinion of the Conseil d’État if you did not meet the legal conditions, or within two years of discovery of the fraud if nationality was obtained by lies: “Les décrets portant acquisition, naturalisation ou réintégration peuvent être rapportés sur avis conforme du Conseil d’Etat dans le délai de deux ans à compter de leur publication au Journal officiel si le requérant ne satisfait pas aux conditions légales ; si la décision a été obtenue par mensonge ou fraude, ces décrets peuvent être rapportés dans le délai de deux ans à partir de la découverte de la fraude.” (article 27-2 of the Civil Code). The Conseil d’État applied exactly this withdrawal where a man naturalised in August 2021 was found to have been sentenced in February 2022 to fifteen months’ imprisonment, twelve suspended, for violence and harassment against his wife, and the minister withdrew the decree in August 2023 (CE, 2nd chamber, 26 November 2024, no. 492338, full decision on Légifrance). Honesty in the file is therefore not moral advice; it is file protection.
B. Refused, adjourned or inadmissible: attacking the right defect before the right court
An unfavourable outcome takes one of three legal forms, and the remedy depends on getting the form right. Inadmissibility (irrecevabilité) means the legal conditions are not met — too short a residence, an invalid permit, a missing language certificate. Rejection (rejet) means the conditions may be met but the minister, in his discretion, does not grant nationality. Adjournment (ajournement) postpones the application and imposes a waiting period or conditions, typically to let the applicant stabilise work or improve integration. The decree states the minister’s hand plainly: “Si le ministre chargé des naturalisations estime qu’il n’y a pas lieu d’accorder la naturalisation ou la réintégration sollicitée, il prononce le rejet de la demande. Il peut également prononcer l’ajournement en imposant un délai ou des conditions” (article 48 of the decree of 30 December 1993, as quoted by CE, 2nd chamber, 14 December 2020, no. 432778, full decision on Légifrance). If the ground of inadmissibility later disappears, nothing stops a fresh application; after a rejection, by contrast, a new application lodged less than five years after notification of the refusal can be closed without examination once the administration has considered any new circumstances raised (service-public.fr, naturalisation by decree). An adjournment should therefore be read as a timetable, not a tombstone: use the imposed period to fix exactly what the decision criticises.
The controlling principle of every challenge is the breadth of the minister’s discretion. “L’autorité administrative dispose, en matière de naturalisation, ou de réintégration dans la nationalité française, d’un large pouvoir d’appréciation. Elle peut, dans l’exercice de ce pouvoir, prendre en considération notamment, pour apprécier l’intérêt que présenterait l’octroi de la nationalité française, l’intégration de l’intéressé dans la société française, son insertion sociale et professionnelle et le fait qu’il dispose de ressources lui permettant de subvenir durablement à ses besoins en France.” (CE, 2nd chamber, 14 December 2020, no. 432778, full decision on Légifrance). In that case the court upheld a refusal grounded on a debt owed to the applicant’s landlord at the date of the decision, even though the applicant was respecting a court-ordered repayment schedule: “en jugeant que le ministre de l’intérieur avait pu retenir dans son appréciation le fait que M. A… était, à la date de sa décision, redevable d’une dette envers son bailleur et alors même que l’intéressé respectait l’échéancier de remboursement fixé par le juge judiciaire, la cour administrative d’appel de Nantes n’a commis ni erreur de droit, ni dénaturation des faits de l’espèce.” (CE, 2nd chamber, 14 December 2020, no. 432778, full decision on Légifrance). British applicants should draw the practical lesson: clear arrears of rent, tax or social charges before applying, and file proof of payment, because even a managed debt can lawfully support a refusal.
The October 2026 Nantes ruling shows how the same discretion operates on assimilation. The applicant, a lorry driver on a permanent contract with a French-language certificate, had his application adjourned for two years because the interview report showed he had been unable to give the dates of the Second World War, explain the role of Parliament, or say which election chooses the President, among other failed answers on French history: “n’a notamment pas été en mesure de citer les dates de la seconde guerre mondiale, ni d’expliquer le rôle du Parlement, pas plus d’indiquer quel scrutin permet d’élire le président de la République” (CAA Nantes, 3rd chamber, 13 October 2026, no. 25NT02098, full decision on Légifrance). The court concluded that “Ces lacunes révèlent une connaissance insuffisante, de la part du postulant, des éléments fondamentaux de la culture française” (CAA Nantes, 3rd chamber, 13 October 2026, no. 25NT02098, full decision on Légifrance), and that the minister, given his wide margin of appreciation, had adjourned the application for two years without any manifest error of assessment — the applicant’s fluent spoken French, exemplary professional integration and permanent contract being, in the court’s words, without effect on the ground for the decision. For British readers the message is stark: professional success and conversational French do not compensate for a failed civic interview, and the only cure is to prepare the history-and-institutions syllabus seriously and, if adjourned, to reapply with demonstrably repaired knowledge once the period expires.
Procedurally, the road is fixed and the deadlines unforgiving. Against a refusal, rejection or adjournment notified after an online application, you have two months from notification to lodge the administrative appeal (recours hiérarchique) to the minister in charge of naturalisations, filed through the form in your online personal space; filed any other way without justified technical impossibility, it can be declared inadmissible (service-public.fr, naturalisation by decree). If the minister answers negatively, or stays silent for four months from receipt of your appeal, you then have two months to bring the judicial challenge before the administrative court of Nantes — the single court competent for these cases nationwide — with the period running from notification of the negative answer, or from the acknowledgment of receipt for computing the implicit refusal (service-public.fr, naturalisation by decree). The Conseil d’État confirmed this centralisation when it transferred a file decided by delegation in Rézé to Nantes, holding that “le tribunal administratif territorialement compétent est, en vertu des dispositions de l’article R. 312-1 du code de justice administrative citées ci-dessus, le tribunal administratif de Nantes” (CE, 27 November 2023, no. 470102, full decision on Légifrance). The general two-month rule for seizing the administrative court — “La juridiction ne peut être saisie que par voie de recours formé contre une décision, et ce, dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée.” (article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice) — frames the whole sequence, so diary every date from the day each letter arrives.
Conclusion
For a Briton settled in France, naturalisation by decree rewards five years of genuine French life, B2 French proved on paper in speaking and writing, a clean record with paid-up debts, and a well-prepared assimilation interview — and it punishes haste, undeclared changes and missed two-month deadlines. Check residence continuity first, book the language test early, clear arrears with proof, learn the civic syllabus as seriously as the vocabulary, and treat any adjournment as a repair list with a date on it rather than a final defeat. The minister’s discretion is wide, but it is reviewable, and the Nantes court corrects refusals built on the wrong facts or the wrong law. Files that respect this order become French; files that skip a step become case law.
Read also
- HMRC Bank Raids After the 2026 Budget: What British Residents in France Must Know
- Forced Out of Your French Job After Brexit: Prise d'Acte, Resiliation Judiciaire and Making the Employer Pay
- Seconded to France After Brexit: the A1 Certificate, the SIPSI Declaration, and How to Challenge an URSSAF Bill