Your French company pays a monthly invoice from its American, British or Emirati parent for group strategy, IT systems, finance support or human resources — or, in the other direction, your French subsidiary bills the foreign parent for services performed from Paris. Either way, the same two questions decide whether the arrangement survives contact with the French tax administration: can the French company deduct the fee from its taxable profit, and who pays French value-added tax (TVA) on a service that crosses a border? This guide answers both, from abroad, with the exact texts and court decisions the administration will throw at you. It assumes the basics are already in place; if they are not, start with our complete setup guide for foreign founders: bank account, Kbis, VAT registration and first hire, which walks through opening the company, obtaining the Kbis (the official identity card of a French company, issued by the greffe, the court registry), and registering for VAT. What follows is the next layer: making intra-group invoices between your French company and its foreign parent stand up to a French tax audit.
I. Can Your French Company Deduct the Fees It Pays Its Foreign Parent?
The short answer is yes, provided the fee pays for real services that actually benefited the French company, at a price that is not excessive. The longer answer is a question of proof, and French case law distributes the burden of proof precisely between you and the tax administration. Get the paperwork right before the audit, and most reassessments fail at this first stage.
A. What must the French company prove first: the amount, the booking and the real service behind the invoice?
French deductibility starts with a short sentence in the French Tax Code (Code général des impôts, CGI). Under Article 39 of that code, applicable to companies subject to French corporate income tax (impôt sur les sociétés, IS): “Le bénéfice net est établi sous déduction de toutes charges, celles-ci comprenant, sous réserve des dispositions du 5, notamment : 1° Les frais généraux de toute nature”. Management fees, head-office costs and technical assistance invoiced by a foreign parent fall squarely into this category of general expenses — but only if the French company proves they are genuine charges, correctly entered in its accounts, with a real service behind them.
The Conseil d’État (France’s highest administrative court) spelled out exactly what that proof looks like in a 15 February 2019 decision, SAS Oteis (formerly Groupe Coplan), no. 407694, concerning assistance services invoiced by a parent company to its subsidiary under an intra-group agreement: “Il appartient, dès lors, au contribuable, pour l’application des dispositions précitées du code général des impôts, de justifier tant du montant des charges qu’il entend déduire du bénéfice net défini à l’article 38 du code général des impôts que de la correction de leur inscription en comptabilité, c’est-à-dire du principe même de leur déductibilité.” The court then defined the content of that justification: “Le contribuable apporte cette justification par la production de tous éléments suffisamment précis portant sur la nature de la charge en cause, ainsi que sur l’existence et la valeur de la contrepartie qu’il en a retirée.” Two elements, then: the nature of the charge, and the existence and value of what the French company got in return.
In practice, that means four piles of documents, assembled before the auditor arrives. First, a written intra-group services agreement, signed and dated before the billing starts, describing each category of service precisely: general management, regional coordination, legal and accounting assistance, IT maintenance, commercial support. In the Coplan case, the court accepted invoices that grouped services by categories such as general group expenses, regional expenses, and legal and accounting assistance, holding that: “Les factures fournies mentionnent des prestations qui, si elles sont regroupées par catégories telles que ” frais généraux groupe “, ” frais de région “, ” assistance juridique et comptable “, peuvent être regardées comme correspondant aux prestations que décrit précisément la convention du 1er janvier 2006.” The lesson for a foreign founder is direct: your management-services agreement must describe the services precisely enough that an auditor can match each invoice line to a clause, and your invoices must use the same vocabulary as the agreement. A monthly lump sum labelled “management fees” with no breakdown is the single most common reason these charges fall.
Second, evidence that the services were actually performed: activity reports, time records, emails, meeting notes, deliverables, travel records of parent-company staff who came to France, tickets from the group’s IT helpdesk showing the French team as requesters. Third, evidence that the French company actually needed and used them: the subsidiary’s replies, the decisions taken on the basis of the parent’s advice, the systems it runs on. Fourth, a pricing method you can explain: hourly rates by staff category, cost-plus with a stated margin, or a flat fee allocated by a stated key (headcount, revenue, time spent). None of these four piles has to be perfect on its own; together, they answer the two questions the Conseil d’État asks — the nature of the charge, and the existence and value of its consideration.
Two traps deserve special attention because the administration raises them in almost every audit. The first is the argument that the invoiced tasks were really part of the corporate office of the French subsidiary’s own manager (mandat social) and therefore cannot also be billed as services. The Conseil d’État rejected a version of this argument in the Coplan case: the minister listed services — general secretariat, financial management, management control, commercial negotiation — and claimed they belonged to the subsidiary manager’s own office, but the court observed that these were: “des prestations, à savoir le secrétariat général, la gestion financière, le contrôle de gestion et la négociation commerciale, qui ne sont pas au nombre des prestations qui ne pourraient être fournies que par les mandataires sociaux”. Day-to-day management support, finance, controlling and sales assistance can be genuine external services even when the subsidiary has its own manager; only tasks that by nature only a legal representative can perform fall outside the scope of billable services.
The second recurring argument is duplication: the subsidiary already employs administrative staff, so the parent’s services must be redundant. Here again the court set the bar for the administration high. The minister had simply listed the subsidiary’s personnel — two secretaries, one administrative manager, one accountant and one sales assistant — and the court held that: “Compte tenu des éléments produits par la société et des arguments avancés par le ministre la cour ne pouvait, sans dénaturer les faits de l’espèce, juger que le ministre apportait la preuve de l’absence de réalité des prestations facturées par la SA Groupe Coplan.” A bare headcount list does not prove duplication; the administration must show that the subsidiary’s own staff actually performed the same tasks. For the foreign founder, the practical advice is to keep the roles visibly distinct: if your French company employs an accountant, the parent’s invoice should cover group consolidation, transfer-pricing documentation or audit support — tasks the local accountant demonstrably does not perform — and the file should say so.
B. What must the tax administration prove to throw the fees out — and why most challenges fail?
Once the French company has produced sufficiently precise evidence on the nature of the charge and the consideration received, the burden shifts. The Conseil d’État stated the shift in the same decision: “il incombe ensuite au service, s’il s’y croit fondé, d’apporter la preuve de ce que la charge en cause n’est pas déductible par nature, qu’elle est dépourvue de contrepartie, qu’elle a une contrepartie excessive dépourvue d’intérêt pour le contribuable ou que la rémunération de cette contrepartie est excessive.” The administration must therefore prove one of four things: the charge is not deductible by nature, it has no consideration at all, its consideration is excessive and of no interest to the company, or the price paid for that consideration is excessive. Each is a real evidentiary burden, not a suspicion.
This matters because auditors routinely proceed by suspicion: a foreign parent, monthly invoices, services that leave no physical trace. Suspicion is not one of the four cases. An auditor who writes that the services “could have been” performed by the subsidiary’s own staff, or that their value “seems” disproportionate, without producing comparables, internal evidence or a demonstration of the absence of consideration, has not met the standard the Conseil d’État requires. That is precisely why the Coplan reassessment was annulled: the administration’s file contained assertions about the manager’s role and a staff list, and the court ruled that material could not support a finding that the invoiced services lacked reality.
None of this means management fees are untouchable. Where the fee genuinely has no consideration — a royalty for a brand the subsidiary never uses, strategic advice that never arrives, IT charges for systems the French team cannot access — the administration can and does win, by proving the absence of consideration. Where the price is manifestly disconnected from the service — a small sales subsidiary paying its parent several times its own payroll for generic “coordination” — the excessive-remuneration branch applies, and the transfer-pricing rules examined below add a second blade. The defence is therefore always the same file: a precise agreement, detailed invoices, traces of performance, traces of use, and a pricing method with comparables. Companies that keep that file from day one usually settle or win; companies that try to reconstruct it during the audit usually lose. If your French subsidiary is already paying such fees without this file, building it now — before any audit notice — is the highest-value action this article can recommend, and it costs nothing but method.
Readers who also move money between group companies as loans rather than services should note the parallel regime: shareholder current-account advances carry their own interest-rate caps and deduction limits, examined in our companion guide on shareholder loans to your French company: interest-rate caps, deduction and treaty relief.
II. How Do Cross-Border Billing Rules Change the Answer?
Deductibility is only the first filter. Because the other party sits outside France, two further regimes apply on top of it: transfer-pricing control, which second-guesses the price, and VAT, which decides which country taxes the service. A fourth formality — shareholder approval of agreements with the controlling parent — conditions the corporate validity of the whole arrangement in the most common vehicle foreign founders use, the SAS (société par actions simplifiée, the flexible joint-stock company).
A. Transfer pricing: when the price itself creates a presumption against you, and how to rebut it
Article 57 of the French Tax Code is the provision auditors cite when a French company does business with a related foreign company. Its opening sentence is worth quoting in full: “Pour l’établissement de l’impôt sur le revenu dû par les entreprises qui sont sous la dépendance ou qui possèdent le contrôle d’entreprises situées hors de France, les bénéfices indirectement transférés à ces dernières, soit par voie de majoration ou de diminution des prix d’achat ou de vente, soit par tout autre moyen, sont incorporés aux résultats accusés par les comptabilités.” Overpaying a foreign parent for services is one of the textbook “other means” of indirectly transferring profits out of France, and the administration may add the excess back into the French company’s taxable result. The same article extends the rule to companies under the dependence of an enterprise or group that also controls companies outside France, so the provision catches the standard foreign-founder structure — a French subsidiary controlled by a foreign holding — without discussion.
The decisive question is who must prove what about the price. The Conseil d’État answered it on 7 November 2023 (Société Alphadif, no. 471310), and the answer cuts both ways: “lorsqu’elle constate que les prix payés par une entreprise établie en France à une entreprise étrangère qui lui est liée sont supérieurs à ceux pratiqués par des entreprises similaires exploitées normalement, c’est-à-dire dépourvues de liens de dépendance, l’administration fiscale doit être regardée comme établissant l’existence d’un avantage qu’elle est en droit de réintégrer dans les résultats de l’entreprise établie en France, sauf pour celle-ci à justifier que cet avantage a eu pour elle des contreparties aux moins équivalentes.” If the administration produces comparables — prices charged between independent companies for similar services — showing your price is higher, a presumption arises and the burden moves to you to justify countervailing benefits of at least equivalent value. Classic countervailing benefits include access to the group’s clients, technology, purchasing power or financing that the French company demonstrably exploits; they must be documented, quantified where possible, and at least equivalent to the excess.
But the same decision sets the mirror rule, which protects companies when the administration has done no comparative work: “A défaut d’avoir procédé à de telles comparaisons, l’administration fiscale n’est, en revanche, pas fondée à invoquer une présomption de transfert de bénéfices mais doit démontrer qu’une libéralité résulte d’un écart injustifié entre le prix convenu et la valeur vénale du bien cédé ou du service rendu.” Without comparables, there is no presumption; the administration must positively demonstrate that a gift results from an unjustified gap between the agreed price and the market value of the asset or service. An auditor’s bare assertion that a fee “looks high” is legally worthless at this stage. For the foreign founder, the practical consequence is twofold: keep your own comparables (quotes from independent providers for equivalent IT, accounting or HR support; the group’s cost base plus a stated margin with evidence that independent providers charge similar margins), and, if challenged without comparables, require the administration to prove the unjustified gap rather than volunteering justifications it has not earned.
The comparison method itself was validated in detail by the Conseil d’État on 6 June 2018 (SCS General Electric Medical Systems, no. 409645), a case about a French distributor buying medical devices exclusively from related foreign group suppliers. The court recalled that Article 57 applies to corporate income tax “en vertu de l’article 209 du même code”, and upheld a reassessment built by comparing the French company’s operating results with those of independent distributors. The comparison does not require identical twins: the court accepted a sample including trading companies whose turnover was not identical to the taxpayer’s and which, like the taxpayer, sold traded goods exposed to competition on the French market. Transposed to management fees, this means the administration may benchmark your parent’s hourly rates or margins against independent consulting, IT-services or accounting firms serving the French market — and it means your own defence file should contain the same kind of benchmark, assembled first. Article 57 adds a procedural sting worth knowing: “A défaut d’éléments précis pour opérer les rectifications prévues aux premier, deuxième et troisième alinéas, les produits imposables sont déterminés par comparaison avec ceux des entreprises similaires exploitées normalement”, and where transfer-pricing documentation requested by the administration is missing or partial, the tax base is assessed from the information available to it under the adversarial procedure. A company that refuses to document its method does not block the reassessment; it merely lets the administration choose the comparables alone.
Two drafting consequences follow for the intra-group agreement. First, state the pricing method in the agreement itself — cost-plus with the margin and its justification, hourly rates with staff categories, or allocation keys with their rationale — so the method is contractual, not reconstructed. Second, review the method when the business changes: a start-up subsidiary that needed intensive parent support in year one may no longer need it in year three, and a flat fee unchanged while local staff triple is exactly the pattern that invites a comparables-based reassessment. Groups that answer a transfer-pricing challenge with a contemporaneous method note and independent quotes usually negotiate; groups that answer with narrative usually pay. Note that dividend flows obey a different withholding and treaty logic, covered in our guide to paying dividends abroad: withholding tax, treaties and payment mechanics, and that the overall corporate-tax computation — rates, instalments and loss relief — is detailed in our French corporate-tax basics for foreign owners.
B. VAT and company approvals: who self-assesses the tax, who deducts it, and who must vote on the agreement?
VAT on cross-border services follows a simple territorial rule with demanding paperwork. Article 259 of the French Tax Code provides that: “Le lieu des prestations de services est situé en France : 1° Lorsque le preneur est un assujetti agissant en tant que tel et qu’il a en France : a) Le siège de son activité économique”. In the standard business-to-business case, the place of taxation is where the customer is established: a service supplied by a foreign parent to its French subsidiary, acting as a taxable person (assujetti) in France, is taxable in France. The tax is then collected through the reverse-charge mechanism (autoliquidation): where business-to-business services covered by Article 259(1°) are supplied by a taxable person not established in France, “la taxe doit être acquittée par le preneur” — the French customer self-assesses the tax. Concretely, the foreign parent issues its invoice without French VAT, and the French subsidiary self-assesses French VAT on its own VAT return and, where entitled, deducts the same amount — frequently a neutral operation in cash terms, but a declaratory obligation whose omission draws penalties. The official French business portal confirms the mechanism for intra-EU services: where the customer is a taxable person, VAT is in principle charged in the customer’s Member State (TVA applicable aux échanges de prestations de services dans l’UE, entreprendre.service-public.fr).
The mirror situation — the French subsidiary billing the foreign parent for services performed from France — follows the same rule in reverse. Where the foreign parent is a taxable person established in another EU Member State, the French company issues an invoice excluding VAT and the parent self-assesses in its own state; the French issuer must then show mandatory wording on its invoice: where the customer self-assesses the VAT, the French seller states the word autoliquidation (self-assessed) on the bill (same official guidance on intra-EU services invoicing). Where the parent sits outside the EU — the United States, the United Kingdom, the Gulf states — the service is generally outside the scope of French VAT, but the invoice must still identify both parties’ status correctly and the French company keeps the contract and proof of the customer’s foreign establishment in its file. In both directions, both parties’ VAT identification numbers appear on the invoice, and the French company’s EU recapitulative reporting must reflect the flow. Errors here are among the cheapest to prevent and the most commonly penalised: missing “autoliquidation” wording, a foreign customer’s VAT number never checked in the VIES system, or a reverse charge forgotten on the French return.
On the deduction side, the right to deduct follows the reality of the supply. Article 271 of the French Tax Code opens with the principle: “La taxe sur la valeur ajoutée qui a grevé les éléments du prix d’une opération imposable est déductible de la taxe sur la valeur ajoutée applicable à cette opération.” But the Conseil d’État, in the VAT part of the same Coplan decision of 15 February 2019, drew the line that protects the Treasury against fictitious invoicing: “un contribuable n’est pas en droit de déduire, de la taxe sur la valeur ajoutée dont il est redevable à raison de ses propres opérations, la taxe mentionnée sur une facture établie à son nom par une personne qui n’est pas le fournisseur réel de la marchandise ou de la prestation effectivement livrée ou exécutée.” The same judgment allocates the burden: where the invoicing party is properly registered and presents itself as a taxable person, “il appartient à l’administration, si elle entend refuser à celui qui a reçu la facture le droit de déduire la taxe qui y est mentionnée, d’établir qu’il s’agit d’une facture de complaisance et que le contribuable le savait ou ne pouvait l’ignorer.” The VAT analysis therefore converges with the corporate-tax analysis: real supplier, real service, real trace — and the administration must prove accommodation invoicing, not merely suspect it. A file that wins on corporate-tax deductibility will normally win on VAT deduction too, because both turn on the reality of the service.
Finally, the corporate-law formality that foreign founders most often miss. In an SAS controlled by a foreign parent — the standard structure — a services agreement with that controlling shareholder is a regulated agreement (convention réglementée). Article L. 227-10 of the Commercial Code requires: “Le commissaire aux comptes ou, s’il n’en a pas été désigné, le président de la société présente aux associés un rapport sur les conventions intervenues directement ou par personne interposée entre la société et son président, l’un de ses dirigeants, l’un de ses actionnaires disposant d’une fraction des droits de vote supérieure à 10 % ou, s’il s’agit d’une société actionnaire, la société la contrôlant au sens de l’article L. 233-3.” The shareholders then vote on that report: “Les associés statuent sur ce rapport.” Where the SAS has a single shareholder, the formality is lighter but not absent: “il est seulement fait mention au registre des décisions des conventions intervenues directement ou par personnes interposées entre la société et son dirigeant, son associé unique ou, s’il s’agit d’une société actionnaire, la société la contrôlant”. Unapproved agreements still produce their effects, but “à charge pour la personne intéressée et éventuellement pour le président et les autres dirigeants d’en supporter les conséquences dommageables pour la société” — the interested party bears the harmful consequences. In a tax audit, an agreement that was never reported or minuted looks like an afterthought, whatever its economic merits; in a shareholder dispute, it looks worse. The approval mechanics, the nullity risks and the borderline cases are examined in our dedicated guide to regulated agreements between your French company and its foreign owner. Have the report drawn up, hold the vote, and record a sole-shareholder decision in the register each year the agreement runs: three gestures that cost an afternoon and remove an entire line of attack.
Conclusion
Management fees between a French company and its foreign parent are neither forbidden nor suspect in themselves; they are deductible general expenses when they pay for real services at a defensible price, taxed where the business customer sits under the reverse charge, and valid when the shareholders have approved them. The file that carries all three answers is the same: a precise written agreement signed before billing begins, detailed invoices in the agreement’s vocabulary, traces that the services were performed and used, a stated pricing method with independent comparables, correct VAT wording and self-assessment, and a yearly shareholder report and vote recorded in the company’s books. Assembled from day one and reviewed when the business changes, that file turns the two hardest audit questions — prove the service, justify the price — into routine verifications. Assembled during the audit, it convinces no one. Foreign founders who run their French subsidiary from abroad cannot attend every meeting or sign every page in person, but they can impose this discipline by email, electronic signature and calendar reminders — and that discipline, more than any structuring, is what keeps intra-group billing safe in France.
Read also
- Your French Subsidiary Pays You Interest on Your Shareholder Loan: France's Rate Cap, Deduction Limit and the File That Survives an Audit
- You Must Part With Your First French Employee While You Live Abroad: Dismissal Procedure, Severance Cost and Labour Court Risk
- You Live Abroad and Want to Buy an Existing French Company: Share Deal or Fonds de Commerce, Approval Clauses, Price Warranty and Closing Formalities