You have found the flat in Paris, signed the compromis de vente (preliminary sale agreement) at the estate agent’s office or before the notaire (public officer who authenticates conveyances), and paid the deposit into the notaire’s hands. Then the telephone call comes: the seller has received a higher offer, has changed their mind, or simply stops answering and fails to attend the signing appointment for the final deed. For a foreign buyer managing the purchase from London, New York, Dublin, Toronto or Sydney, the shock is real, and so is the practical problem: flights booked, a mortgage offer with an expiry date, a current lease to give up. French law, however, treats the seller’s second thoughts with remarkable severity. Once the preliminary agreement is signed, the sale is in principle already made, and the seller cannot walk away by returning the deposit or paying a small indemnity. This guide explains, first, why the signed agreement binds the seller, and second, the three remedies open to the buyer: forcing the transfer through the courts, collecting the agreed penalty, or ending the deal and claiming damages. It is written for non-French buyers of residential property in France, with the Paris and Ile-de-France specifics integrated where they matter.
I. The signed agreement already binds the seller: the sale is made
English-speaking buyers often read the compromis de vente as an option or a reservation: a document that fixes the price while leaving both sides free until the final deed, the acte authentique (notarial deed of sale), is signed. That reading is wrong in the ordinary case. French sale law considers the sale complete as soon as the parties agree on the thing and the price, and the Court of Cassation draws the full consequences against a seller who refuses to complete. The only questions are what kind of preliminary agreement was signed and what its deadline clauses say.
A. The bilateral compromis is a completed sale: agreement on the thing and the price
The standard compromis de vente is a bilateral promise, a promesse synallagmatique (mutual promise of sale): the seller undertakes to sell and the buyer undertakes to buy, subject only to the conditions suspensives (conditions precedent) listed in the agreement, typically the buyer’s mortgage approval, the absence of a pre-emption exercise, and the satisfactory town-planning and title searches. Article 1589 of the Civil Code states the governing principle: « La promesse de vente vaut vente, lorsqu’il y a consentement réciproque des deux parties sur la chose et sur le prix. » This means that a promise of sale counts as a sale as soon as both parties mutually agree on the property and the price. Article 1583 adds the mechanism: « Elle est parfaite entre les parties, et la propriété est acquise de droit à l’acheteur à l’égard du vendeur, dès qu’on est convenu de la chose et du prix, quoique la chose n’ait pas encore été livrée ni le prix payé. » In plain terms, the sale is perfect between the parties, and ownership passes to the buyer as against the seller, from the moment thing and price are agreed, even though the property has not been delivered and the price has not been paid (article 1589, Civil Code, Légifrance; article 1583, Civil Code, Légifrance). The later signature of the acte authentique is therefore a matter of form, proof and registration against third parties, not the moment the contract is born. A seller who believes that only the notarial deed commits them is mistaken, and that mistake is expensive.
The Court of Cassation confirmed this analysis in the strongest possible terms on 24 September 2026, in a dispute where the seller, a French territorial authority in French Guiana, had signed a mutual sale promise with a three-year period and then refused to proceed to reiteration before the notaire even though the buyer had paid the price into the notaire’s hands and twice formally demanded completion (Cass. 3e civ., 24 Sept. 2026, No. 24-18.981). The Third Civil Chamber quashed the appeal judgment that had released the seller, holding: « En application des deux derniers, il est jugé, en matière de promesse synallagmatique de vente, que, sauf stipulation contraire, l’expiration du délai fixé pour la réitération de la vente par acte authentique ouvre le droit, pour chacune des parties, soit d’agir en exécution forcée de la vente, soit d’en demander la résolution et l’indemnisation de son préjudice (3e Civ., 1er octobre 2020, pourvoi n° 19-16.561, publié). » This means that, unless the parties agreed otherwise, the expiry of the period set for redoing the sale by notarial deed gives each party the right either to sue for forced performance of the sale or to seek its termination with compensation for their loss. For the foreign buyer, the message is direct: when the contractual signing date passes without the seller, the buyer holds the choice of weapons, not the seller. Either the buyer compels the transfer, or the buyer ends the deal and makes the seller pay. The seller cannot impose a third outcome, a quiet abandonment with the deposit simply returned.
One reservation in that same ruling must be read with care, because it decides many files. The Court recalled that the outcome differs where the deadline is expressly coupled with lapse of the agreement, or where the parties made reiteration before the notaire a constitutive element of their consent: in those cases the sale can fall away with the expired term. Concretely, before doing anything else, the buyer must re-read the compromis clause fixing the completion date and ask one question: does the clause merely organise the calendar, or does it state that the agreement lapses if the deed is not signed by that date? Standard Paris notarial forms organise the calendar; lapse clauses are the exception and must be express. Where the clause is an ordinary timetable, the seller’s absence at the appointment changes nothing to the buyer’s rights. Buyers preparing their first French acquisition often benefit from understanding the wider framework in which these preliminary agreements operate, as explained by French real-estate lawyers in Paris advising foreign buyers on purchase structures, before the dispute stage is even reached.
A frequent source of confusion should be cleared up at this point. The ten-day withdrawal right that every foreign buyer hears about protects the buyer alone, never the seller. Article L. 271-1 of the Construction and Housing Code provides: « l’acquéreur non professionnel peut se rétracter dans un délai de dix jours à compter du lendemain de la première présentation de la lettre lui notifiant l’acte. » This means that a non-professional buyer may withdraw within ten days starting the day after the first presentation of the letter notifying them of the agreement (article L. 271-1, Construction and Housing Code, Légifrance). The seller has no mirror right of repentance. Once that ten-day period expires without withdrawal, and once the conditions precedent are satisfied or their deadlines pass, the buyer is bound symmetrically, and from that point on a seller who refuses to complete is simply a defaulting debtor. The deposit the buyer paid, usually five to ten per cent of the price and held by the notaire as stakeholder, is then not a price the seller can pay to buy back their freedom: it is the buyer’s money, held for the completion, and its fate follows the outcome of the dispute, as Part II explains.
B. The unilateral promise: the seller’s change of mind changes nothing
Some transactions use a different instrument, the promesse unilatérale de vente (unilateral promise of sale). Here only the seller is bound from the outset: the seller, called the promettant (promisor), grants the buyer, the bénéficiaire (beneficiary), an option to purchase at an agreed price within an agreed period, and the sale is formed if and when the beneficiary lifts the option. Foreign buyers encounter this structure when the seller wants time to find substitute accommodation, or when the parties agree exclusivity while searches are done. The seller sometimes assumes that, since the buyer has not yet opted, the seller remains free to revoke the promise before the option is exercised, for instance by selling to a higher bidder who appears in the meantime. Since the contract reform that entered into force on 1 October 2016, that assumption is false, and the Court of Cassation applies the new rule without indulgence.
Article 1124, paragraph 2, of the Civil Code provides: « La révocation de la promesse pendant le temps laissé au bénéficiaire pour opter n’empêche pas la formation du contrat promis. » This means that revoking the promise during the period left to the beneficiary to opt does not prevent the formation of the promised contract (article 1124, Civil Code, Légifrance). If the beneficiary lifts the option within the period, the sale is formed despite the seller’s revocation, and the seller who refuses to sign can be forced to complete exactly like the seller under a bilateral compromis. The same article adds a weapon against the higher-bidder scenario: a sale concluded in breach of the unilateral promise with a third party who knew of the promise is void, so the substitute buyer who was informed of the existing promise takes nothing secure. For the foreign beneficiary, the practical consequence is that the seller’s revocation letter should never be treated as the end of the file: the option should still be lifted in time and in the contractually required form, because that act preserves every remedy.
The leading illustration is the judgment of 11 September 2025, where members of one family had promised a house to a buyer company by notarised deed of 21 November 2016 for 720,000 euros, with the option period extended by the parties, and seven of the promisors then failed to attend the signing appointment of 26 November 2018; the beneficiary sued for forced sale and the Aix-en-Provence appeal court rejected the claim by applying the pre-reform law, treating the promise as lapsed because the promisors had renounced before the option was lifted (Cass. 3e civ., 11 Sept. 2025, No. 24-13.774). The Court of Cassation quashed that reasoning. It recalled first the transitional rule: « Il résulte du premier de ces textes que les dispositions de l’ordonnance du 10 février 2016 entrent en vigueur le 1er octobre 2016 et que les contrats conclus avant cette date demeurent soumis à la loi ancienne. » This means that the provisions of the 10 February 2016 reform entered into force on 1 October 2016 and that contracts concluded before that date remain governed by the old law. Since the promise dated 21 November 2016 fell under the new law, the court of appeal had violated article 1124 by giving effect to the promisors’ revocation: « Selon le second, la révocation de la promesse unilatérale de vente pendant le temps laissé au bénéficiaire pour opter n’empêche pas la formation du contrat promis. » This means that, under that second text, revocation of the unilateral sale promise during the beneficiary’s option period does not prevent formation of the promised contract. Three operational lessons follow for foreign buyers. First, check the date of the promise: agreements signed before 1 October 2016 remain under the old case law, which was less protective. Second, lift the option strictly within the period and in the form the promise requires, usually by bailiff’s notification or registered letter to the notaire, because expiry of the option period without action ends the right. Third, where the seller has already sold to a third party, verify urgently what that third party knew: a substitute buyer informed of the promise holds a voidable title, while a good-faith one may leave only a damages claim against the seller.
II. Three remedies when the seller refuses to sign: force the sale, take the penalty, or end the deal paid
Once it is established that the seller is bound, the buyer chooses the remedy that fits their situation: keep the property by forcing the transfer, keep the money by collecting the contractual penalty, or walk away from a compromised deal with resolution and damages. Whichever route is chosen, the first step is identical and mandatory: put the seller formally on notice. Article 1221 of the Civil Code makes forced performance available only « après mise en demeure », meaning after the debtor has been formally required to perform (article 1221, Civil Code, Légifrance). In practice the buyer’s counsel has a commissaire de justice (court enforcement officer, formerly huissier de justice) serve a formal demand ordering the seller to attend a specified notaire’s office on a specified date to sign the acte authentique, warning that court proceedings for forced sale will follow. That document fixes the default date, stops the seller from later claiming they were ready and willing, and starts the paper trail every subsequent claim needs.
A. Forcing the sale: formal notice, then a court-ordered transfer
The forced-sale action, the action en exécution forcée (claim for forced performance), asks the civil court to order the seller to sign and to declare that the judgment will stand in place of the deed if the seller still refuses. This is precisely the relief the buyer sought in the 24 September 2026 case: condemnation of the seller to sign the notarial deed, a declaration that the judgment would count as the sale absent signature, application of the penalty clause, and damages. The Court of Cassation’s holding, quoted in Part I, validates the structure of that claim: on expiry of the reiteration period, each party may either demand forced performance or demand resolution with compensation. The court seized of the case examines whether the conditions precedent were satisfied, whether the buyer was themselves ready to complete, evidenced by the mortgage offer, the funds, and attendance at the appointments, and whether any lapse clause defeats the claim. Where those checks pass, the seller is ordered to transfer, and the property the buyer chose is the property the buyer keeps, whatever higher offer arrived in the meantime.
Foreign buyers should understand the realistic timetable and mechanics rather than imagining an emergency procedure. The forced-sale claim is brought before the tribunal judiciaire (ordinary civil court) of the place where the property sits, so for a Paris flat that means Paris, and it follows the ordinary written procedure, not the fast-track eviction-style hearing. Months, not weeks, should be budgeted, and the mortgage offer’s validity should be extended in the meantime, with the lender informed in writing that completion is delayed by the seller’s default rather than by any fault of the borrower. Attendance at the signing appointments is organised through the notaire in charge of the sale, who draws up official records of non-appearance, the procès-verbaux de carence (records of default), which become decisive exhibits. A buyer who cannot fly to Paris for every step acts through written powers of attorney and French counsel; distance changes the logistics, never the rights. Readers dealing with a Paris purchase from abroad will find the practical context of Paris conveyancing, including how local counsel and the notaire divide the work, in the presentation of real-estate legal services in Paris for English-speaking buyers, which complements the procedural analysis developed here.
Two limits must be stated honestly. First, forced performance is excluded where it has become impossible: if the seller has already conveyed the property to a good-faith third party who knew nothing of the prior promise, the court cannot take the property back from that innocent owner, and the buyer’s claim converts into damages against the seller, potentially with annulment proceedings against a bad-faith substitute buyer as described in Part I. Speed therefore matters: as soon as the seller’s refusal is clear, the buyer publishes their claim and sues, rather than negotiating for months while the seller disposes of the asset. Second, the lapse-clause exception recalled by the Court of Cassation must be verified on the actual compromis: where the parties expressly made the notarial reiteration within the period a condition of the sale’s very existence, or attached express lapse to the deadline, the forced-sale claim fails and only the monetary remedies remain. This is why the first hour of any such file is spent reading the preliminary agreement line by line, not writing letters.
B. Money remedies: recovering the deposit, collecting the penalty, and claiming damages
Many buyers, particularly those buying from abroad with a mortgage deadline and a life to organise, prefer money to months of procedure: recover the deposit, collect the contractual penalty, and move on to another property. French law supports that choice firmly, provided the compromis contains the right clause. Most professionally drawn preliminary agreements include a clause pénale (penalty clause), a fixed sum the defaulting party pays the other if they fail to complete. The deposit paid to the notaire is normally returned to the buyer when the seller defaults, since the failure is not attributable to the buyer, and the penalty comes on top as the agreed price of breach. Where the compromis instead labels sums as a dédit (withdrawal payment) allowing a party to walk away freely, that clause must be read exactly as written, because a genuine right-to-withdraw clause produces different effects from a penalty clause; the wording chosen by the drafter decides which regime applies.
The penalty clause is enforced as written, but the judge controls excess. Article 1231-5 of the Civil Code provides: « le juge peut, même d’office, modérer ou augmenter la pénalité ainsi convenue si elle est manifestement excessive ou dérisoire. » This means that the court may, even on its own initiative, reduce or increase the agreed penalty where it is manifestly excessive or derisory (article 1231-5, Civil Code, Légifrance). The control is real but the threshold is high: the penalty must be manifestly excessive, not merely generous. The judgment of 19 September 2019 shows how courts apply that test to preliminary sale agreements: a seller sued its defaulting buyer for 18,000 euros under a clause headed deposit plus 36,000 euros under a clause headed penalty, the buyer itself arguing that both clauses were truly penalty clauses cumulating to a manifestly excessive 54,000 euros, and the Lyon appeal court assessed the combined amount before rejecting the excess claim, an approach the Court of Cassation approved, noting that the appeal court « Attendu, d’autre part, que la cour d’appel a pris en compte le montant cumulé des deux clauses pour exclure le caractère manifestement disproportionné de la pénalité prévue par les parties en cas de non-réalisation de la vente ; » This means the appeal court took into account the combined amount of both clauses in order to rule out the manifestly disproportionate character of the penalty the parties had set for non-completion of the sale (Cass. 3e civ., 19 Sept. 2019, No. 18-18.614). The lesson cuts both ways and matters directly to the buyer facing a defaulting seller: all forfeit sums are added together when the court tests excess, so a compromis that stacks a kept deposit, a penalty clause and a flat indemnity may see the total moderated, while a single clearly drafted penalty proportionate to the price survives. At the drafting stage, the buyer therefore wants one clean penalty clause at a serious but defensible level; at the dispute stage, the buyer claims every sum the compromis provides and lets the seller argue excess.
Beyond the fixed penalty, the buyer who suffered greater proven loss may seek resolution of the sale with compensation, the second branch of the alternative recognised by the Court of Cassation in the 24 September 2026 ruling: termination plus indemnification of the loss. Recoverable loss typically includes wasted expenditure, surveyor and broker fees engaged for the failed purchase, the additional cost of a replacement property where a price rise can be documented, temporary accommodation costs caused by the delayed move, and, for an investor, the rental income lost during the dispute period. Each head must be proved with invoices, contracts and dated correspondence; French courts compensate demonstrated loss, not annoyance. All of these monetary claims share the same limitation regime: article 2224 of the Civil Code provides that « Les actions personnelles ou mobilières se prescrivent par cinq ans à compter du jour où le titulaire d’un droit a connu ou aurait dû connaître les faits lui permettant de l’exercer. » This means that personal and movable actions are time-barred after five years running from the day the holder of the right knew, or should have known, the facts enabling them to sue (article 2224, Civil Code, Légifrance). Five years is generous, but waiting is still the worst strategy: the seller may become insolvent, the property may pass to a good-faith third party, and the mortgage offer will long have expired. The disciplined sequence is therefore formal notice within days of the missed appointment, counsel’s letter quantifying the penalty and reserving all further claims, then proceedings before the positions harden. One final warning: never sign a mutual release or an amendment « regularising » the situation, however amicable the estate agent sounds, without advice, because a signed release can extinguish the penalty and the damages in a single paragraph.
Conclusion
A seller who refuses to complete after signing the preliminary agreement is not exercising a right but breaching a contract. The bilateral compromis is already a sale once thing and price are agreed, and the expiry of the signing timetable gives the buyer, not the seller, the choice between forced performance and termination with compensation, as the Court of Cassation reaffirmed on 24 September 2026. Under a unilateral promise made since 1 October 2016, the seller’s revocation during the option period does not prevent the sale from forming when the buyer opts, as confirmed on 11 September 2025. The buyer who acts methodically, formal notice through the enforcement officer, preservation of the deposit with the notaire, claim for the penalty with the combined-amount case law in mind, and proceedings within the five-year limitation, either keeps the property chosen or is paid for losing it. What the buyer must never do is treat the seller’s change of mind as the end of the story.
Read also
- Snags After Completion in France: the One-Year and Two-Year Builder Guarantees Foreign Buyers Forget
- Buying a French House With a Septic Tank: SPANC Reports, the One-Year Upgrade Rule and Buyer Remedies
- Security Deposit Not Returned in France: Deadlines, Deductions, 10% Penalty and Recovery for Foreign Tenants and Landlords