Kohen Avocats law firm · Paris

Refrigerator: Can an English Business Reject a Faulty Commercial Fridge After Using It?

Individuals, businesses and directors. Reda Kohen practises real estate law, company law and business law in Paris. First analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) – “Judilibre” and “Légifrance” Open Data databases.

Paris Bar Real estate, company and business law CNB listing on avocat.fr
Reda Kohen, lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar
Reda Kohen
Lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar
Refrigerator: Can an English Business Reject a Faulty Commercial Fridge After Using It?

Recent United Kingdom searches for refrigerator raise a practical question for businesses buying commercial equipment. A commercial refrigerator can seem to work at handover and still fail once staff begin loading it and opening its doors throughout a shift. A café that bought the unit may want a replacement immediately. Its supplier may say that the café accepted the unit by putting it into service. Under the law of England and Wales, in the United Kingdom, the buyer’s ability to reject depends on the contract, the seriousness of the breach and what the buyer did after delivery. A short examination and several weeks of ordinary trading raise different questions. Asking the seller to arrange a repair does not, by itself, amount to acceptance.

This article provides general information on English law for businesses that bought a commercial fridge from a supplier. It covers a sale governed by English law and uses hypothetical examples. A hire agreement, a separate installation dispute or an individual buying mainly for private use calls for a separate analysis. The practical starting point is to put the purchase records next to the delivery and fault records. The purchase records show what the supplier promised. The fault records can show when the buyer first had a fair opportunity to discover the problem, how the supplier responded and whether the buyer communicated a rejection.

By Reda Kohen, lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar.

I. When does a faulty commercial fridge give the buyer a right to reject?

A. Establish what the supplier agreed to deliver

Start with the legal identity of the buyer and seller. Section 2 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 defines a sale contract by reference to the transfer, or agreed transfer, of ownership in goods for a price. A restaurant group can have a purchasing company, a separate operating company and several branches with similar names. The business that paid the invoice or took delivery may be different from the one that made the contract. Match the accepted order and invoice to the correspondence that formed the deal. If the supplier separately arranged installation or introduced a finance provider, locate those agreements too. Identify who sold the equipment, who installed it and which contract assigns responsibility for each task.

Check the purpose of the purchase if a person signed in their own name. Section 2 of the Consumer Rights Act 2015 defines a consumer as an individual acting for purposes wholly or mainly outside their trade, business, craft or profession. A sole trader who buys a display cabinet mainly for a café can be making a business purchase even if the receipt is in their personal name. An individual who buys a model described as commercial mainly for their home raises a different question. Establish the buyer’s purpose and legal identity before borrowing a returns procedure from a consumer information page.

For a business sale, section 14 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 sets out two distinct routes. A seller acting in the course of business generally supplies goods subject to an implied term of satisfactory quality. The standard is the one a reasonable person would expect, taking account of the description, price where relevant and other circumstances. Ordinary fitness, safety and durability can matter. The same section also addresses reasonable fitness for a particular purpose that the buyer made known to the seller, expressly or by implication, subject to the statutory reliance qualification. The pre-order emails are especially useful if the requested duty was unusual for that model.

For example, a caterer specifies a cabinet that must recover to a stated temperature after repeated door openings during service. The supplier recommends a model after receiving the specification. Preserve both the requirement and the recommendation. Compare that exchange with an order placed by model number after the caterer chose equipment independently. The model’s ordinary performance may still matter in that second example. The record supporting an implied term about a special operating requirement will differ, particularly if the buyer supplied its own technical selection and the seller simply quoted a price.

Build the evidence around the alleged defect. Record the model, serial number, stated operating range, room conditions, installation clearances and any commissioning readings. For a temperature complaint, retain timed readings from a suitable instrument and record where each measurement was taken. A display value, the air temperature on a shelf and the temperature of a stored product can differ. An engineer’s report is more useful if it identifies the test conditions, reproduces the symptom where possible and explains whether the issue points to the unit, its installation or the conditions in which it was used. Preserve any readings that contradict the complaint as well. A complete record makes it easier to work out whether the same symptom recurs after a change in conditions.

A discounted or refurbished machine still needs to be assessed against the bargain actually made. Under section 14(2C), a defect specifically drawn to the buyer’s attention before the contract can fall outside the implied quality term. The same provision deals with defects that a pre-contract examination ought to reveal and defects apparent on reasonable examination of a sample in a sale by sample. An acknowledged dent on a side panel is one thing. A fault that becomes apparent only when the compressor has been under load may raise a different issue. Keep the original listing and photographs and record exactly what the seller disclosed before the order. A revised product description or a later explanation may leave a different impression from the material available when the price was agreed.

B. Decide whether the breach supports rejection and read the contract terms

For a sale governed by English law, section 14(6) classifies the implied terms of satisfactory quality and particular fitness as conditions. Section 15A of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 qualifies the remedy in a business sale. If a breach of an implied term covered by that section is so slight that rejection would be unreasonable, it can be treated as a breach of warranty. The seller must show that the breach was that slight. The section applies unless a contrary intention appears in, or can be implied from, the contract. This question comes before acceptance. A buyer may have inspected and objected promptly and still need to establish that the breach is serious enough for the remedy sought.

A damaged trim panel on an otherwise conforming unit and a cabinet that repeatedly fails to hold the agreed temperature present different commercial problems. A sensible comparison looks at the term breached, the effect on actual operation, the extent of the defect and any evidence about its persistence. For example, an alarm that operates reliably but sounds slightly quieter than expected calls for better evidence about the agreed specification and the effect on the business. A cabinet repeatedly unable to meet the supplier’s stated operating range calls for measurements under the expected load and an explanation of why the supplied unit cannot meet it. Record the effect on use and the facts behind it. The value of the machine or the amount of disruption alone cannot identify the contractual breach.

Read the sales terms from the point at which the order was made. Section 55 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 allows implied obligations to be varied in specified ways subject to the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977. An express term displaces an implied statutory term only if it is inconsistent with it. A commercial warranty offering a technician visit for a year can sit alongside other obligations. Locate any clause the supplier says limits rejection or confines relief to repair and compare how the contract deals with those obligations. Keep the signed terms, the quotation and the version of any online conditions supplied or referred to before ordering. A link printed on a later invoice is a reason to investigate which terms the parties agreed.

Sections 6 and 11 of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 matter if a business seller relies on a contract term to exclude or restrict liability for breach of the relevant statutory implied obligations. Section 6 permits that restriction only to the extent the term satisfies the reasonableness requirement. Section 11 assesses a contract term by reference to the circumstances known, or which ought reasonably to have been known or contemplated, when the parties made the contract. It puts the burden of showing reasonableness on the party relying on the term. For a monetary cap, the section specifically identifies available resources and access to insurance among the relevant considerations. Keep any record of how the price and protection were negotiated, which options were available and whether a different level of cover was discussed.

A useful file distinguishes three documents that can otherwise be confused. The supply agreement sets out what was sold. A manufacturer warranty details the support the manufacturer has promised under that warranty. An engineer’s service ticket records the work someone carried out. All three can help explain what happened, but the signature on a service ticket should be checked for what it actually confirms. It may acknowledge a visit, a replaced part or successful testing. Identify the supplier’s actual position in writing if it relies on the manufacturer’s warranty or the engineer’s sign-off to refuse rejection. For background on the firm’s practice in Paris, see its business law expertise.

II. What should the buyer do after testing or using the fridge?

A. Reconstruct the examination, continued use and repair history

Section 34 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 provides that, unless otherwise agreed, a seller tendering delivery must on request give the buyer a reasonable opportunity to examine the goods for conformity. Section 35 then addresses acceptance. Subject to the protection for goods not previously examined, acceptance can arise from telling the seller that the goods have been accepted or from an act after delivery inconsistent with the seller’s ownership. It can also arise from retaining the goods without communicating rejection after a reasonable time. Whether the buyer had a reasonable opportunity to examine the goods is relevant to that timing inquiry. These provisions make the sequence of events more useful than a bare calculation from the date on the invoice.

At delivery, record which checks were possible. Staff can often verify the model, visible condition and obvious transport damage while the driver is on site. Checking temperature stability may require the machine to be fitted, powered and commissioned. A service counter might need a representative pattern of loading and door openings to reproduce the issue. Note when the machine was first available to test, who tested it, when the relevant symptom first occurred and whether installation or missing components had prevented an earlier examination. If the delivery paperwork contains an acceptance statement, preserve the exact form and any notes added at the time. Its significance depends on its terms and the circumstances in which it was signed.

Make the chronology concrete. In a hypothetical case, a kitchen receives a cabinet on Monday, the supplier’s installer connects it on Wednesday, and employees see an alarm during the first full service on Friday. Staff record the time, readings and use of the cabinet and send them to the supplier that day. Those facts enable both sides to assess which inspection was possible and when the first useful test happened. In another case, managers observe the same fault from the first shift, continue to use the cabinet for routine storage and send only a maintenance query several weeks later. Here, the use and the wording of the correspondence are particularly important. Section 35 supplies the reasonable-time test. The dates in either example do not set a statutory period.

If the cabinet stays in operation while an alternative is arranged, record when and why the business kept using it, what was stored in it and when ordinary use stopped. Keep equipment and stock records separate so that a precaution taken to protect stock is visible in its own right. An internal note that a machine was being tested is easier to assess if it identifies the test, the person responsible and the time the test ended. A general statement made weeks later that everything was provisional leaves more room for dispute. Correspondence with the supplier is particularly important when the buyer’s staff and the supplier understood the purpose of continued operation differently.

Section 35(6) provides that asking for or agreeing to repair by or under an arrangement with the seller does not alone establish acceptance. Keep the message authorising the visit and request a report identifying what was diagnosed and what changed. A reset, a temporary adjustment and a replacement component tell different stories about whether the defect was resolved. Note the operating conditions after the visit and whether the same symptom recurred. The repair request is one part of the history. Other conduct, communications and retention remain relevant to the statutory acceptance inquiry. A buyer planning a further repair should check who is authorised to approve it and what the existing correspondence says about the status of the goods.

B. Communicate the decision and preserve a remedy if rejection is disputed

Where the buyer has a right to reject delivered goods, section 36 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 generally makes notice of refusal sufficient and does not require the buyer to send the goods back, unless the parties agreed otherwise. Check how the contract requires notices to be given. A written record can identify the purchase order, serial number, defect and reasons for rejection. It can distinguish a rejection from a complaint or a request to send a technician. Address it to the contractual seller and retain evidence of sending and any reply. If the order included multiple units, be clear about exactly which unit or units the notice concerns.

Agree practical arrangements for inspection or collection. A heavy cabinet may need safe disconnection and an agreed collection route, especially if it forms part of a fitted counter. Before removal, preserve photos of the installed condition, operating readings, the serial plate and any replaced part still available. Record who disconnects or collects the equipment and what was taken. If the supplier wants the unit returned for testing, ask for written confirmation of the arrangements and the purpose of the shipment. The notice and the physical movement of the equipment are separate events. A pickup record can prove where the unit went while leaving the parties’ positions on the breach or remedy to their correspondence.

A multi-unit order calls for an additional check. Section 35A of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 can preserve an existing right to reject affected goods where the buyer accepts some goods, including all unaffected goods where there are any, subject to a contrary contractual intention. Section 35(7) treats acceptance of goods forming part of a commercial unit as acceptance of that whole unit when division would materially impair its value or character. Three separately priced and independently operable cabinets give a buyer a different factual record from a single integrated refrigeration line sold as a unit. Use the specification, drawings and order to identify how the equipment was supplied and whether division would materially affect its character or value.

For a non-severable contract, section 11 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 generally reduces breach of condition to breach of warranty once the buyer has accepted the goods or part of them, subject to section 35A and any contractual term preserving rejection. Section 53 gives a buyer dealing with a breach of warranty a route to claim damages or to raise the breach against the price. The statutory measure is the estimated loss directly and naturally resulting in the ordinary course of events. For a breach of a quality warranty, the starting point is the difference at delivery between the value of the goods supplied and their value had they met the warranty. A refund figure and a damages estimate therefore answer different questions.

Keep a separate record for each claimed loss. A quote for repairing the cabinet, the price of temporary substitute storage and a list of discarded stock each need different evidence. If temporary storage was hired, keep the start and end dates and the paid invoice. If a stock loss is claimed, identify the stock, how its condition was assessed and why the claimed loss is attributed to the defect. Preserve the records showing efforts to avoid or reduce loss. Consider what the supplier’s contractual limits say and whether they are enforceable, along with what the engineer can establish about causation. A single aggregate figure makes it hard to assess which part of the claim follows from the breach.

A buyer can use the same file to assess a commercial settlement. If the supplier offers a replacement, establish its specification, delivery and commissioning dates, who will remove the first unit and what the proposed agreement says about any claim already made. If the supplier offers an allowance towards repair, identify the remaining fault, the proposed work and the assumptions in the engineer’s quote before comparing the allowance with the loss. Where the parties disagree about whether the buyer accepted the goods, preserve the chronology and the rejection notice even while discussing a repair or replacement. A clear file shows which remedy the buyer seeks, why it says it is available, and what it can prove if the seller disputes it.

The same evidence can help distinguish a continuing defect from a fresh problem. A cabinet may cool properly after a repair while a loose door seal still causes intermittent temperature rises. A later failure under different conditions could have a different cause. Compare the initial report, the repair report and the post-repair readings before describing the later failure as a recurrence. Correspondence and logs should identify when stored items were moved, when replacement equipment became available and when the business stopped relying on the original unit. That sequence lets both parties assess the operational impact without treating every cost incurred after delivery as a loss caused by the supplier.

Conclusion

A business may still be able to reject a commercial fridge after putting it into service. The English-law analysis starts with a right to reject for the particular breach and then asks whether the buyer retained that right. The agreed specification, the conditions of the first meaningful test, any period of routine use and what the buyer communicated to the supplier can all affect the answer. A request for a seller-arranged repair does not alone settle the question of acceptance.

A buyer considering rejection should identify the contract and unit, preserve the inspection and repair records and communicate its decision clearly to the seller. Where the right to reject has been lost or the breach is too slight to justify rejection, the buyer can assess a warranty remedy on its own evidence. In either case, a dated chronology and a supported calculation of loss give both sides a concrete basis for resolving the dispute.

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

What our clients say

4,9212 Google reviews
kader ladjouzi
2 months ago

Best real estate law and business law lawyer in Paris. A humane and attentive lawyer, with a wonderful team. Thank you, Maître KOHEN

Translated from French

Janou SAMUEL
3 months ago

Thank you to Maître KOHEN for his analyses of recent case law on fraudulent non-disclosure in property sales. It reassures me about an action for annulment that I am considering after buying a house affected by serious defects intentionally concealed by the seller and not reported by the estate agent; also defects (rising damp) characterised by spreading through-cracks and damp stains, not reported by the estate agent… Worse, defects concealed by the latter or at his instigation, under a coat of paint and by polystyrene tiles glued to the ceiling of a bedroom. And the said estate agent drafted the preliminary contract, which of course contains no information about any of these defects. Just to add that, being 77 years old and suffering from cognitive impairment, I am certain that the estate agent thought I would not be able to discover the deception and above all to establish the fraudulent intent, still less to bring legal proceedings given the complexity and length of the procedure... That is why I am opting for the criminal route, insofar as the intentional concealment of the defects by the seller and then by the estate agent amounts to the fraudulent manoeuvres of art. 313-1 of

Translated from French

Paul MALIK (powlo)
5 months ago

Maître Reda KOHEN assisted me in a dispute concerning a sale agreement with a defaulting party. He provided professional and responsive support, and I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

Rayan Kallout
6 months ago

I highly recommend Maître Reda Kohen. Thanks to his explanations, I was able to recover my security deposit in a situation that seemed blocked. He was responsive, clear, and very professional. A big thank you for his invaluable help!

Translated from French

Naji Jouahri
6 months ago

Excellent support from Maître Kohen in a case combining business law and real estate law. Clear legal analysis from the first meeting, right through to the hearing. Professional and accessible lawyer, I highly recommend his firm in Paris 17.

Translated from French

Halim Tunde
6 months ago

Maître Kohen assisted me in recovering unpaid debts from a defaulting tenant. Procedure mastered from start to finish, from the payment order to eviction. Human, attentive, and always reachable. Thank you for your work.

Translated from French

Cha
6 months ago

As a young student living in an apartment, my landlord tried to make me leave my accommodation even though he had sent me no termination notice. I therefore contacted Mr. Reda Kohen to help me as I couldn’t handle the situation alone. In just 3 days everything was resolved, Maître Kohen defended me and accompanied me with an irreproachable level of commitment and efficiency. I can only recommend his professionalism!

Translated from French

Asmaa Maazaz
8 months ago

I turned to Maître Kohen for a complex real estate dispute and I highly recommend his firm. He is very professional; he thoroughly analyzed my case from the very first appointment and clearly explained the possible options. Thanks to his expertise, we achieved a very favorable outcome. Responsive, a good teacher, and committed, he is a lawyer you can truly trust. Yours faithfully, Miss Maazaz

Translated from French

chaymaa aouadi
8 months ago

I called upon Maître Reda Kohen, a real estate lawyer in Paris, and I am fully satisfied with his support. Very professional, responsive and attentive. He quickly analyzed my case, clearly explained the legal strategy and effectively defended my interests. Thanks to his expertise and determination, we obtained a very favorable outcome. I highly recommend Maître Kohen to anyone looking for a real estate lawyer in Paris.

Translated from French

Fatima Arbouhi
8 months ago

Excellent real estate lawyer. Professional, responsive and attentive, he perfectly met my expectations and accompanied me with great seriousness throughout my case. I highly recommend his services.

Translated from French

Laurent Joulaud
9 months ago

Maître Kohen helped us enormously in our case of eviction of a tenant who hadn't paid rent for many months. He was quick and efficient in drafting the summons and the various actions. He was also very clear about the different stages of the procedure and gave us almost instant feedback when he received documents to communicate. I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

H
9 months ago

The best real estate lawyer in Paris, I recommend without hesitation.

Translated from French

Sokona Dembele
9 months ago

Maître Kohen is an extremely competent and rigorous lawyer. His professionalism, responsiveness, and the quality of his support were remarkable—I weigh my words. Thanks to serious and perfectly mastered work, we obtained a favorable outcome despite a delicate case. He is the best real estate lawyer. I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

Hamid Agouz
1 month ago

I was pleasantly surprised by the responsiveness of Mr Reda Cohen, who took the time to answer my questions about my case instantly. It has become so rare these days to find a lawyer who is so available, responsive and attentive, even when it is simply a matter of answering questions. His answers are clear, precise and reassuring. You can tell that he takes the time to understand the situation and to provide relevant answers. Beyond his excellent ratings on Google, it is above all this availability and this seriousness that make the difference. Many thanks to Mr Reda Cohen for his professionalism and his responsiveness. I highly recommend!

Translated from French

Salon Sisters
1 month ago

Thank you, Maître Kohen, for your professionalism, your responsiveness and your seriousness. You handled my case perfectly, with a great deal of attentiveness, rigour and efficiency. I was very satisfied with your support and the work carried out. I recommend him without hesitation!

Translated from French

Frederic Lopes
1 month ago

Excellent professional. I strongly recommend him for his dedication and expertise.

Translated from French

Mitalie Talie
1 month ago

Great business law lawyer in Paris, attentive, available and understanding. I would come back if I have a problem.

Translated from French

Siko7801 rouger
1 month ago

Thank you for this very humane and professional advice. I strongly recommend.

Translated from French

Coralie Natation
1 month ago

I highly recommend Maître Kohen’s firm for its availability, its responsiveness and its very great professionalism. Thank you for the many pieces of advice and the efficiency of your firm!

Translated from French

Amir
8 months ago

Excellent expertise in real estate law from Me Reda Kohen

Translated from French

Beaudrique Abao
1 month ago
Krep Events Traiteur Breton
1 month ago

very clear article

Translated from French

Zakaria Airbnb
1 month ago
Gabriele
1 month ago