If you have retired to France from Britain, two different bills arrive on the same income. The first is income tax, worked out through the France–United Kingdom double tax treaty. The second is a set of French social charges — the contribution sociale généralisée (CSG, the general social contribution), the contribution au remboursement de la dette sociale (CRDS, the contribution repaying the social debt) and, on some income, the contribution additionnelle de solidarité pour l’autonomie (Casa, the additional solidarity contribution for personal autonomy) plus a prélèvement de solidarité (solidarity levy). Many British pensioners discover this second bill only when the avis d’imposition (tax assessment notice) lands, and some pay it when they did not have to. Since the Court of Justice decided de Ruyter in 2015, a person who is genuinely covered by another country’s social security scheme cannot be made to fund the French schemes twice over — and that protection survived Brexit for people who hold the right papers, above all the S1 healthcare certificate. This guide explains which rate applies to each of your incomes, when your British cover exempts you from the CSG and the CRDS, why one 7.5 per cent levy survives every exemption, and how to reclaim money wrongly charged before the deadline expires. The declaration mechanics of the State Pension itself are covered in our companion guide on where your UK State Pension is taxed and declared; this article owns the charges side of the bill.
I. Do you owe French social charges on your British income, and at what rate?
A. How much France takes from your pensions: which rate of CSG applies to you
Once you are fiscally domiciled in France — broadly, once France is the centre of your home and economic life — your worldwide pensions fall into the French net for social charges. British State Pension, personal pensions and former-employer pensions all count as revenus de remplacement (replacement income), the same family as French retirement pensions. The statute is blunt about the headline rate: article L. 136-8 of the Social Security Code provides that “Sont assujetties à la contribution au taux de 8,3 % les pensions de retraite, et les pensions d’invalidité.” But 8.3 per cent is only the top of a four-step scale, and where you sit on it depends on your revenu fiscal de référence (reference tax income, the benchmark figure printed on your French tax notice), that is on the income you declared two years earlier.
For 2026 the administration applies four CSG rates to retirement pensions — zero, the reduced rate of 3.8 per cent, the middle rate of 6.6 per cent and the full rate of 8.3 per cent — by reference to the 2024 reference income shown on your 2025 tax notice, as the official guidance on CSG and CRDS on earned and replacement income sets out. For a single part (tax share, the unit by which France divides household income) the 2026 bands run from zero CSG up to 13,048 euros of reference income, the reduced 3.8 per cent rate from 13,049 to 17,057 euros, the middle 6.6 per cent rate from 17,058 to 26,472 euros, and the full 8.3 per cent rate above 26,472 euros, with higher bands for households holding one and a half, two or more shares. Two practical consequences follow. First, the full 8.3 per cent rate only bites once your income has crossed the reduced band in two consecutive years, so a one-off spike does not catapult you straight to the top. Second, your CSG band decides the rest of the bill: pay CSG at the zero rate and you are freed from both CRDS and Casa; pay it at the reduced rate and you are freed from Casa while the CRDS remains due; from the middle rate upwards all three apply. The CRDS takes a further 0.5 per cent of the pension and the Casa 0.3 per cent, the Casa being identified on the official Casa page as the contribution that funds support for elderly and disabled people.
Three misunderstandings cost British pensioners money at this stage. The first is believing that a pension taxed only in Britain escapes French social charges altogether. Income tax and social charges obey different logic: the double tax treaty divides the right to tax, while the social charges follow your fiscal domicile and your social security cover, so a pension that Britain alone may tax can still attract French charges unless an exemption applies. The second is treating the State Pension and a private pension differently for charges purposes. Both are replacement income and both feed the same reference-income test, which is why the revaluation of the State Pension under the triple lock — analysed in our piece on what British pensioners keep after the triple-lock reworking — can quietly push a household from the reduced into the middle band. The third is ignoring the first French tax return: newcomers who file late or file badly lock in a wrong reference figure that then drives two years of CSG rates, a point developed in our guide to the first French tax return after arrival. Get the domicile date and the declared amounts right the first time, because the charges follow the declaration.
B. What France takes from your rent, savings and gains: the 17.2 per cent stack
Everything that is not a pension or wages goes through a different machine. Rental income from a French or British letting, interest, dividends and capital gains on shares or property are revenus du patrimoine (capital income) or produits de placement (investment income), and the base is set by article L. 136-6 of the Social Security Code, which makes persons fiscally domiciled in France liable on the net amount used for income tax and lists rents, life annuities bought for consideration, investment income and the gains and profits subject to income tax, and by article L. 136-7 for investment products. The rate side is fixed by the same article L. 136-8: 9.2 per cent CSG on this income instead of the pension scale. Add the CRDS at 0.5 per cent and the solidarity levy at 7.5 per cent and the total reaches 17.2 per cent, exactly as the official table on social charges on capital income presents it — 9.2 per cent CSG, 0.5 per cent CRDS, 7.5 per cent solidarity levy, 17.2 per cent in total — for rental income, for gains on property and for investment income alike.
For a British household in France this stack bites in three familiar places. Rental income from a British buy-to-let declared on the French return attracts the full 17.2 per cent on top of income tax, subject only to the treaty tax credit that wipes out the double income tax but never the social charges; the letting angle, forms 2047 and 2042 included, is worked through in our guide for the British landlord living in France. Interest and dividends from British accounts suffer the same stack, with French paying-agent deductions applied during the year and squared on the return. Capital gains hurt most because the base is large: selling a former French home after leaving, or selling British shares while French-resident, triggers 19 per cent income tax plus the 17.2 per cent stack, and the S1 exemption discussed below is often the only lawful way down. Note carefully what the 7.5 per cent piece is. Unlike the CSG and the CRDS, which help fund the compulsory social security schemes, the solidarity levy feeds national solidarity funds — employment and housing support — and that destination takes it outside the European coordination rules. The Paris administrative court of appeal put the boundary plainly when it recalled that the Conseil d’Etat, by its decision No. 395065 of 18 October 2017, had held that none of the benefits financed by the three funds to which that solidarity levy was then assigned fell within the scope of the 2004 coordination regulation, so that applying the levy breached neither the single-legislation principle nor the ban on double contributions: CAA Paris, 31 July 2020, No. 19PA03063. The lesson is symmetrical and expensive to forget. Win the European argument and the CSG plus the CRDS — 9.7 points — fall away; the 7.5 per cent solidarity levy stays in every case.
II. When your British cover exempts you and how to get wrongly charged money back
A. Who the S1 really exempts, and what proof the French judge demands
The exemption has one source and one condition. The source is the European rule that a person covered by social security coordination is subject to the legislation of a single state only. The Conseil d’Etat stated it in these terms: where persons fall within the scope of the regulation they are subject to the legislation of one Member State only, determined under the rules in articles 11 to 16, “ce qui exclut dès lors toute possibilité de cumul de plusieurs législations nationales pour une même période et, de manière corollaire, qu’un même revenu soit exposé au paiement de doubles cotisations” — CE, 25 October 2024, No. 473997. The condition is that you must genuinely be covered by the British scheme at the time the charge bites. The founding judgment, de Ruyter of 26 February 2015 (C-623/13), held that levies on capital income “présentaient, lorsqu’ils participaient au financement des régimes obligatoires de sécurité sociale, un lien direct et pertinent avec certaines des branches de sécurité sociale énumérées à l’article 4 de ce règlement”, so that they fell within the regulation even though assessed on capital income regardless of any professional activity — as recalled by CAA Paris, 31 July 2020, No. 19PA03063. In plain terms: CSG and CRDS on your rents and gains fund French social security, so Britain’s scheme and France’s cannot both charge you for the same period. The same court added the limits set the following years: the regulation “ne s’applique qu’à des personnes qui sont ou ont été soumises à la législation de sécurité sociale d’un ou de plusieurs États membres de l’Union européenne sans que le fait d’être un ressortissant ou un résident fiscal d’un État membre, non affilié au régime de sécurité sociale de cet État, suffise à faire entrer dans le champ du règlement”. Nationality or a tax bill is not enough; real cover is everything.
For a British pensioner that cover normally takes the shape of an S1. The S1 is the portable certificate by which the United Kingdom, which pays your State Pension, accepts the cost of your healthcare in France; once registered you receive treatment on the same basis as a French insured person while remaining under the British scheme. The British government’s own guidance confirms the route is open after Brexit: you may acquire the right to apply for a UK S1 when you start drawing a UK State Pension, frontier workers — people who work in one state and live in another — may also qualify, and Once the S1 is issued, it must be registered with the local CPAM office, the local health fund, and cover then works for the holder and dependants on the same basis as for French insured persons — Healthcare for UK nationals living in France, GOV.UK. If instead you work in France on a French contract, or you live in France without any British cover and join Puma (the universal French health protection) on residence grounds, you are under the French scheme and the exemption is not yours to claim. That is exactly where claims collapse. In one Nantes case the claimant invoked Great Britain but had never worked there nor ever been domiciled there, so the court held him subject to French legislation under article 11 of Regulation 883/2004 — CAA Nantes, 7 October 2022, No. 21NT00872 — which restated the de Ruyter payoff as follows: “qu’il n’était pas permis à un Etat membre d’assujettir à des prélèvements fiscaux, dans la mesure où ils financent des prestations de sécurité sociale, des contribuables affiliés à un régime de sécurité sociale dans un autre Etat membre”. Affiliated elsewhere: protected. Affiliated nowhere but France: charged.
Paperwork decides as many cases as principle. The Paris court in the 2020 case above rejected a claimant who produced a British tax return bearing a National Insurance number, a belated request for an affiliation certificate that came to nothing, and a later letter from the British tax authority saying only that he had resided in the United Kingdom and that primary taxing and contribution rights had lain with London — these, the court wrote, “n’établissent pas la réalité de cette affiliation”. A tax return is not an affiliation certificate, a National Insurance number is not proof of cover for the year charged, and a certificate requested years after the event, once the file is already in dispute, carries little weight. Build the file the other way round: an S1 or an A1 certificate covering the very year of the income, the CPAM registration acknowledgment (attestation de droits), and continuous cover with no gap over the period the administration taxed. Two related traps deserve a line each. First, a capital payment does not escape the machine by being one-off: the Conseil d’Etat in the October 2024 decision subjected a Swiss reversion pension paid as a single lump sum to CSG, CRDS and Casa, reading the pension-contributions article of the regulation as setting no ceiling at the amount of the French-source pension — CE, 25 October 2024, No. 473997. British lump sums, including the quarter many savers take tax-free at home, meet the same analysis on the charges side even where the treaty spares the income tax. Second, the exemption never touches the 7.5 per cent solidarity levy, as the official capital-income table itself warns: residents of France who work in an EEA state or Switzerland and belong to that state’s compulsory scheme residents in that position are not liable to CSG and CRDS, and only the 7.5 per cent solidarity levy remains due — service-public.fr. Claim 9.7 points back, never 17.2.
B. How to reclaim and challenge: the complaint, the deadlines and what the courts did in 2024–2026
French procedure gives you two doors and both have clocks. The first door is the réclamation contentieuse (contentious claim) to the tax administration. The law opens this door wide: article L. 190 of the Tax Procedure Book provides that “Les réclamations relatives aux impôts, contributions, droits, taxes, redevances, soultes et pénalités de toute nature, établis ou recouvrés par les agents de l’administration, relèvent de la juridiction contentieuse lorsqu’elles tendent à obtenir soit la réparation d’erreurs commises dans l’assiette ou le calcul des impositions, soit le bénéfice d’un droit résultant d’une disposition législative ou réglementaire.” A wrongly applied CSG-CRDS charge, and an S1 exemption the computer ignored, fit that definition exactly. The clock is strict: article R*. 196-1 of the same book requires claims to reach the administration “au plus tard le 31 décembre de la deuxième année suivant celle” of the assessment, the payment without assessment, or the event giving rise to the claim — so charges paid on 2024 income are generally claimable until 31 December 2026, and each year has its own cut-off. Miss it and the merits no longer matter. One timing subtlety counts for sellers: on a capital gain, the chargeable event is the sale itself — the Paris court noted of a 2014 Paris disposal that it was “à la date de cette cession, qui constitue le fait générateur de l’imposition aux prélèvements sociaux de la plus-value réalisée à cette occasion” that residence and cover had to be tested — CAA Paris, 31 July 2020, No. 19PA03063. Moving back to Britain the year after the sale does not rewrite the cover position on sale day.
The second door is the administrative court, and it opens only after the first is shut or refused. If the administration rejects the claim expressly, or stays silent for six months — which counts as an implied refusal — you have two months from that refusal to petition the tribunal administratif (administrative court): article R. 421-1 of the Administrative Justice Code states that “La juridiction ne peut être saisie que par voie de recours formé contre une décision, et ce, dans les deux mois à partir de la notification ou de la publication de la décision attaquée.” Petition directly without first claiming and the case is thrown out as inadmissible, exactly as the guidance warns for claims for payment. Win, and the money comes back with late interest: article L. 208 of the Tax Procedure Book opens with the rule that “Quand l’Etat est condamné à un dégrèvement d’impôt par un tribunal ou quand un dégrèvement est prononcé par l’administration à la suite d’une réclamation tendant à la réparation d’une erreur commise dans l’assiette ou le calcul des impositions”, the sums already collected are returned to the taxpayer, with the moratory interest the courts routinely add. Recent litigation counsels realism about scope. On 9 October 2026 the Conseil d’Etat declined to admit a challenge to social levies on a 2017 share sale, holding “Le pourvoi de Mme A… n’est pas admis” and “Il n’y a pas lieu de renvoyer au Conseil constitutionnel la question prioritaire de constitutionnalité” — CE, 9 October 2026, No. 515118. A refusal to admit is not a ruling on the merits, and it must never be quoted as one, but it shows the top court is not currently reopening the architecture of these levies: run the proven European-cover argument with dated papers, not a fresh constitutional theory. Concretely, a reclaim file that works contains the S1 or A1 covering the charged year, the CPAM registration proof, the French assessment notices for each year claimed with the CSG-CRDS lines highlighted, and the claim letter sent in a provable form before 31 December of the second year. Ask for discharge of the CSG and CRDS lines and expressly leave the 7.5 per cent solidarity levy out of the demand; claiming it betrays a file the administration will not take seriously.
Conclusion
For a British pensioner settled in France the question is never one question but two. First, which of your incomes carries which charge: your pensions move between zero and 8.3 per cent CSG with the CRDS and sometimes the Casa on top, while your rents, interest, dividends and gains carry the flat 17.2 per cent stack. Second, which scheme covered you when the charge arose: a current S1 registered with your CPAM takes the CSG and CRDS off your capital income but never the 7.5 per cent solidarity levy, and only papers dated to the charged year prove it. Put the two answers together before 31 December of the second year, and the reclaim procedure does the rest.
Read also
- Renewing Your Carte de Séjour in France After Brexit: the New French Language Tests (A2 and B1) British Residents Must Pass — and How to Challenge a Refusal
- British and Applying for French Citizenship After Brexit: Marriage Declaration or Naturalisation, B2 French, Delays and How to Challenge a Refusal
- UK State Pension Now Tops the UK Tax-Free Allowance: What British Retirees in France Pay, Declare and Reclaim After Brexit