The phrase “cyber attacks” is being searched in the United Kingdom. For a business whose cyber insurance is governed by the law of England and Wales, it raises a practical question: what should the business tell its insurer when the policy is about to renew and an earlier incident is still under investigation? The general method is to establish what the business knows, carry out a reasonable search for material information and explain the remaining uncertainty before agreeing the renewal. The business can give a useful account while the investigators are still working.
Consider a company whose service provider flagged unusual activity shortly before a renewal deadline. The company knows when the alert arrived and what measures it took. It may still be checking whether anyone gained access, which services were affected and whether the issue began earlier. The task is to separate those categories so that a decision to insure the next period is based on an accurate account of the risk. A separate exercise is to check whether the incident should be notified under the policy already in force.
This article gives general information on foreign law from Reda Kohen, a lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar. It addresses ordinary commercial insurance contracts governed by the law of England and Wales and uses hypothetical examples throughout. Coverage for a particular incident depends on the policy and the evidence.
I. What a business must present before renewal
A. Tell the underwriter what is known and what remains open
Under section 3 of the Insurance Act 2015, the insured must make a fair presentation before entering into a non-consumer insurance contract. A renewal normally involves entering into a new contract. The business therefore makes a fresh presentation even when it proposes to keep the same insurer, broker and level of cover. The Insurance Act 2015 also applies this duty to a proposed variation, with the focus then on changes in the risk relevant to that variation. Sections 22 and 23 set out when these provisions apply and give the Act territorial extent across the United Kingdom. This article focuses on current contracts governed by the law of England and Wales.
Commercial cover belongs in a different statutory framework from personal cover. Section 2 of the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012 requires a consumer to take reasonable care to avoid a misrepresentation. A company preparing a presentation for its business policy should work from the commercial duty. A director arranging both company cover and personal cover should identify the insured and the contract concerned before applying either standard.
Under section 7 of the Insurance Act 2015, a fact or representation is material if it would influence a prudent insurer in deciding whether to accept the risk and on what terms. For an earlier incident, the question at renewal is what its known features would tell an underwriter about the risk for the coming period. The source of an alert, the system involved, an interruption to business, work to contain the activity and the limits of the investigation can all help answer that question. Whether a loss has been quantified is a separate issue. Even where the company has paid all response costs itself and made no claim, the evidence could still affect an underwriting decision.
The Act gives two routes for the disclosure element of fair presentation. The first is to disclose every material circumstance the business knows or ought to know. Failing that, the information disclosed must be sufficient to alert a prudent insurer to the need to make further enquiries to uncover the material circumstances. This second route calls for enough detail to show where an enquiry would lead. Giving a date range, naming the kind of system affected and describing the unresolved question about access gives the underwriter a starting point. A bare reference to routine IT work might leave the underwriter unaware that an external provider is investigating suspicious activity.
Both routes sit alongside requirements about the quality of the presentation. It must be reasonably clear and accessible to a prudent insurer. A material statement of fact must be substantially correct, and a material statement of expectation or belief must be made in good faith. A concise incident summary can sit alongside an indexed report and supporting records. Put the material facts in the summary and refer to the relevant attachments for detail. This helps the underwriter find the issues without having to reconstruct an incident from a folder of messages or infer its importance from an unexplained alert.
A useful account distinguishes three things. Start with confirmed observations, such as the alert date or the time a service was restored. Then describe the current assessment and who made it. Finally, state which questions remain open and when the next information is expected. If an investigator has confirmed that an account was accessed but has yet to examine the affected records, say what the investigation has established about the account and which records remain to be examined. That gives the insurer a materially different picture from saying that the company has found no evidence of access to data.
Section 3(5) provides exceptions to the obligation to disclose in the absence of enquiry, including where the insurer knows or ought to know the circumstance, is presumed to know it or has waived the information. Section 5 connects those knowledge rules to the people who decide whether and on what terms to take the risk, the information readily available to them and circumstances that an insurer is presumed to know. When the same insurer handled a prior notification, the company can identify when it was made, what documents were sent and what has changed since. This gives the renewal underwriter a way to locate the earlier information and assess its present relevance.
B. Search across the people and organisations that hold the facts
Section 4 of the Insurance Act 2015 identifies the knowledge attributable to an insured company. The starting point is what is known to members of senior management and to the people responsible for arranging insurance. Senior management is defined by a person’s significant role in decisions about managing or organising the insured’s activities. Whoever fills in the renewal form may therefore hold only part of the information for which the business is responsible. The statute also gives a separate test for what the insured ought to know: what a reasonable search of available information should have revealed.
In an ordinary renewal, the people making the search may include operations, finance and whoever oversees the incident response. Which people and records matter depends on the business. In a small company, a director may have the outage information and an external provider may hold the technical incident report. In a group policy, a subsidiary covered by the contract may have records that the insurance team at the parent company has never seen. Section 4 expressly contemplates available information held by another person, including an agent or a person for whom the contract provides cover. Start by identifying the insured entities and the people likely to have the facts for each one.
A reasonable enquiry can begin with a short set of specific questions. Ask what triggered the investigation, when the organisation discovered the issue, which activities or services were affected and whether the problem was confined to a particular part of the business. Ask what changed in response and whether the provider or internal team has produced an interim account. Check whether any third-party demands or claims have been received and whether the status set out in an earlier notification has changed. The scope of a reasonable search depends on the information available and the features of the risk. The Act does not set a universal number of people or records to check.
A management team should reconcile conflicting accounts before submitting an answer. The finance team may describe an interruption in terms of when it resumed processing invoices, while the operations team may describe when customer orders could again be dispatched. Both can be accurate and measure different things. Stating the relevant time periods and activities gives the underwriter context for the reported interruption. Where logs are missing or a provider cannot yet answer, say whose information was requested, what has been supplied and what remains unresolved. Keep the request and response together so that later evidence can be placed alongside what the business knew at renewal.
The questionnaire helps organise the presentation. If a question asks only about claims made in the past year, a truthful answer about claims may leave a material incident or open investigation undisclosed. Additional information can be supplied in an accompanying document. Conversely, if a question uses a term that the business cannot interpret with confidence, it can give the underlying facts and ask the insurer how it wants the question answered. A qualification belongs next to the answer it changes. An underwriter reading the form should be able to see immediately that a summary answer depends on the scope of an investigation or a particular date.
The presentation should remain up to date while renewal is being agreed. Under section 7, a representation may be withdrawn or corrected before the contract is entered into. If a first response says the incident was confined to one service and an interim report subsequently identifies another, send the correction as soon as the new position can be accurately described. Identify the original answer and the change. Ask for confirmation of receipt before the contract is concluded and record which version the insurer had at that point. The date on which a policy starts may differ from the date the parties enter into the contract.
II. How to manage cover and preserve the renewal record
A. Keep the existing policy and the new proposal on separate tracks
When an incident is discovered near renewal, retrieve the current insurance policy, endorsements and the documents that describe how to notify the insurer. Check what the contract calls a claim, an incident or a circumstance, and what trigger makes notification relevant. Identify the recipient, vehicle and timing specified by the policy. Obtain the corresponding wording for the proposed period and compare the two. A date on a renewal form may indicate when a new period starts, while a reporting clause may use a different point in time to assess the existing cover.
The renewal presentation tells an insurer what it needs to assess a proposed contract. A notification tells the insurer that receives it about a matter under an existing contract. Sending the same facts to the same organisation can serve both purposes if the requirements of both processes are met. Do not assume that an entry in the renewal questionnaire has reached the claims recipient or satisfies that policy’s reporting requirement. Check the reporting channel and keep the confirmation. Likewise, when relying on what the incumbent insurer already knows, review what the original notification actually contained and whether the presentation should include material developments.
Consider an example. A company receives an alert in October. As part of its investigation it temporarily pauses an ordering system and restores the service the following day. A supplier is still reviewing activity when the company is arranging a December renewal. The business can send the notification required by the existing policy on the facts then known, if the wording calls for one. It can separately disclose the alert, interruption, restoration and open enquiry for the renewal. If the investigator later changes the assessment before the company agrees the contract, the business can update the renewal presentation. It can also check whether the current insurer requires a supplementary report.
Record the relationship between the old and proposed terms. Check how each wording deals with events known before inception, the date from which cover may extend backwards, any limitation relating to an existing incident and any continuation or reporting provision. Terms will vary. Ask the prospective insurer to identify any change in scope it intends to make in response to the disclosure and have it reflected in the written offer or endorsements. A higher premium may address the underwriter’s assessment of the business generally. A separate exclusion could address a specific incident. Each needs to be read for its own effect.
Businesses may also face the separate question of when a sum due on a claim under the earlier contract must be paid. Section 28 of the Enterprise Act 2016 inserted section 13A into the Insurance Act 2015. The inserted term requires an insurer to pay sums due within a reasonable time, which includes a reasonable time to investigate and assess the claim. The provision also deals with reasonable grounds for disputing the claim. That framework concerns payment under the existing contract and applies subject to the statutory application rules. An open assessment under the earlier policy still leaves the business with a separate decision about material information for renewal.
For businesses coordinating insurance with other agreements, a commercial contract review can cover the dates and notice channels in supplier, outsourcing and customer contracts as well as the policy. In practice, a service provider may be the first to learn of the incident and may be required under its agreement to send information to the business. Decide who will collect that information, who will review it for the insurance presentation and who will make any notification. Keep a common factual chronology so the descriptions can be compared, while observing the different requirements of the documents involved.
B. Record what the insurer would have done with the information
A breach of the duty has consequences under section 8 of the Insurance Act 2015 only if the insurer shows that it would have declined the contract or entered into it on different terms had there been a fair presentation. That is a separate test from materiality. A fact can be capable of influencing a prudent insurer’s assessment, while the actual insurer still has to establish how the omission or misstatement affected its own underwriting decision before it has a statutory remedy. The insurer also bears the burden of showing that a qualifying breach was deliberate or reckless if it relies on that classification.
The default remedies for contracts are in Part 1 of Schedule 1 to the Act. Where the qualifying breach was deliberate or reckless, the insurer may avoid the contract and refuse all claims, and need not return premiums paid. For other qualifying breaches, the response depends on what the insurer would have done. If it would have declined the contract altogether, it may avoid it and refuse all claims, but must return the premiums. If it would have offered different non-premium terms, it may require the contract to be treated as if it contained them. If it would have charged more, it may also reduce what it would otherwise pay on a claim in the proportion provided by the Schedule.
Suppose the only relevant difference would have been a premium of £15,000 instead of the £12,000 actually charged. If the amount otherwise due on a claim were £100,000, the statutory proportion in that illustration would be 80 per cent, or £80,000. The figures are hypothetical. If the insurer would also have added an exclusion, the terms that would have applied must be considered in deciding what amount would otherwise be due. The example illustrates why a business should keep the quote history: the premium and terms quoted after a disclosed development may become more useful evidence than a later reconstruction of what an underwriter might have offered.
A proposed mid-term change can require its own fair presentation under section 2. Part 2 of Schedule 1 provides separate remedies for qualifying breaches concerning variations. For example, the insurer’s response may depend on whether it would have agreed to the change and on the effect of the variation on the total premium. When a negotiation combines a change to the current contract with an offer for the next period, keep separate copies of each proposal, the information supplied for it and the final agreement. The date a variation was agreed and the date the renewal was concluded may matter to different questions.
Sections 16 and 17 also matter when reading commercial wording alongside the Act. The Act allows the parties to depart from certain defaults to the insured’s disadvantage, subject to conditions that include sufficient steps to draw attention to the term before agreement and clarity about its effect. The applicable characteristics of insureds and the circumstances of the transaction are taken into account. Review any clause said to modify the operation of the statutory default, along with the documents bringing it to the business’s attention. The existence of an exclusion addressing the scope of cover and a clause said to modify a statutory remedy each raises its own question.
Maintain a small renewal file that can be understood later without asking its author to reconstruct the process. Keep the completed questionnaire, the dated incident chronology, the documents sent with the presentation, the enquiries made and their answers, subsequent corrections, and the offer and acceptance. Record where confirmed facts came from and what was qualified at the time. Preserve the distinction between what the business sent, what its broker sent on and what the insurer acknowledged. When the presentation used a choice of limits or terms, save which version the business accepted. If the insurer asks later how an incident was described, the file should let the parties work from the same documents.
A later review should start with the relevant contract and a reliable timeline. Identify the presentation the insurer says was deficient, the circumstance said to have been material and the evidence available when the contract was made. Then identify the underwriting decision the insurer says it would have taken and the remedy claimed under the policy or statutory framework. An investigation can change substantially after renewal. Keep the later findings in the file with their own dates so that the assessment of what was known or reasonably discoverable at renewal rests on the information then available.
Conclusion
A business renewing cyber cover under the law of England and Wales should make a fresh, clear presentation of the risk. For an earlier incident, that means checking what the relevant people and records reveal, describing the material facts and identifying the questions that are still open. Correct material answers that change before the contract is made. Preserve what was sent and the terms agreed. Check separately whether the existing policy calls for notification and whether the renewal wording limits cover for earlier events. This gives the business and the insurer a reliable record of the risk they discussed and the cover they agreed while the investigation was still in progress.
Read also