Brent Cross shopping centre, in north London, rose sharply among searches in the United Kingdom on 18 November 2026, together with related searches asking whether the centre was closed. This article does not describe any event there and makes no statement about the centre, its owners, its managers or the businesses that trade in it. The discussion that follows is general in scope: it sets out a method for any shop tenant in England and Wales whose shopping centre shuts its doors, for an afternoon or for several weeks, whatever the cause.
For a retailer, the question quickly becomes financial. Is the next rent payment still due in full? Can the service charge be reduced for days when the malls were shut? What happens if the tenant simply deducts the lost days from its next payment? Is there an insurance claim for the trading that was lost? Under the law of England and Wales, the answer starts with the lease rather than with the closure. A lease may suspend rent in defined circumstances. Where it does not, the remedies available to landlords for unpaid commercial rent, notably commercial rent arrears recovery under the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 and forfeiture under the lease, make a unilateral deduction a risky choice.
By Reda Kohen, lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar. This is general information about the law of England and Wales, not advice on a particular lease. Scotland and Northern Ireland have their own rules and are not covered.
I. Is rent still payable while the shopping centre is closed?
A. Start with the rent covenant and the suspension clause
The first document to open is the lease itself, together with any deed of variation, side letter or licence that changed it. The rent covenant tells the tenant what it must pay, when and how. In a shopping centre lease it is usually accompanied by separate payment obligations for the service charge, the insurance rent and sometimes a marketing or promotion contribution. Read the payment clause word for word. A commercial lease may require payment without any deduction, counterclaim or set-off. If the lease contains that kind of wording, the tenant has already agreed, in principle, not to reduce a payment because it believes it has a claim against the landlord. That clause does not settle every dispute, but it changes the starting point: the tenant needs a provision in the lease that suspends or reduces the rent itself, rather than a reason to keep money back.
The next step is to find the clause that does suspend rent, if there is one. It may be headed suspension of rent, rent cesser, abatement or loss of rent. Its structure is usually the same. There is a trigger, such as damage to or destruction of the premises by one of the insured risks. There is a consequence for the premises, typically that they become unfit for occupation or use, or that they cannot be reached. There is a measure, such as the whole rent or a fair proportion of it. And there is a period, which may run until the premises are reinstated or end after a fixed number of years. Each element must be checked against what actually happened at the centre.
A closure is not the same thing as damage. A centre may close because of a power failure, a security alert, a police instruction, a flood in a service corridor, a fire in another unit or a decision of the management team taken for safety reasons. Some of these events cause physical damage and some do not. If the clause is triggered only by damage caused by an insured risk, a closure without damage will not meet the first condition, however inconvenient it is for the tenant. If there was damage, the tenant then has to ask whether it was caused by one of the risks listed in the definition of insured risks, whether it affected the unit or only the common parts, and whether the clause extends to damage that prevents access to the unit rather than damage to the unit itself. Some clauses expressly mention access to the premises or other parts of the centre; others refer only to the premises demised. The difference can decide the claim.
Several other clauses deserve attention at this stage. The lease may give the landlord an express right to close or restrict the common parts temporarily, for example in an emergency, for security reasons, to carry out works or to comply with the requirements of a public authority. Where such a right exists and was exercised, a tenant who complains about the closure is arguing against the wording it signed. The lease may also contain a keep-open covenant obliging the tenant to trade during the centre’s opening hours. Check whether that obligation is expressly suspended while the centre is closed, so that the tenant is not exposed to a separate allegation of breach. Where part of the rent is calculated on turnover, a closure will usually reduce the turnover element automatically, because it is measured on sales actually made, while the base rent remains due unless a clause says otherwise.
Tenants sometimes look for an answer outside the lease. They argue that a closure has brought the lease to an end or suspended it by operation of law, or that a court should read into the lease a suspension of rent that the parties did not write. Those arguments depend on case law that this guide does not examine, and on facts that will rarely be clear in the days after a closure. A tenant who withholds rent on the strength of such an argument carries all the risks described in the next section if the argument fails. The prudent course is to treat the express wording as the measure of the tenant’s rights and to build any wider argument separately, with the documents in hand.
The recent statutory exception confirms the point. Parliament did intervene in commercial rents after the coronavirus restrictions, but in a targeted way. Under section 3 of the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Act 2022, a protected rent debt is a debt under a business tenancy consisting of unpaid protected rent, and rent is protected only if the tenancy was adversely affected by coronavirus and the rent is attributable to occupation during the protected period applying to that tenancy. The scheme therefore concerns pandemic-related arrears. It offers no route for a closure that has a different cause, such as a security incident, a utility failure or works in the centre.
The arbitration route created by the same Act was also limited in time. Under section 9 of the Commercial Rent (Coronavirus) Act 2022, where the parties to a business tenancy disagreed about relief from a protected rent debt, either of them could make a reference to arbitration “within the period of six months beginning with the day on which this Act is passed”, subject to any extension made by regulations under subsection (3). A tenant facing a closure today should therefore not expect a statutory relief scheme to take over the negotiation. Its rights come from the lease and from any agreement it can reach with its landlord.
B. The cost of withholding rent: arrears recovery and forfeiture
A tenant who decides to deduct a closure period from its rent without a clause to rely on is making a bet. If its reading of the lease is wrong, the landlord has two main statutory and contractual tools to recover the arrears or recover the unit, and each has a cost beyond the sum in dispute.
The first tool is commercial rent arrears recovery, known as CRAR. The old self-help remedy has gone: section 71 of the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 states that “The common law right to distrain for arrears of rent is abolished.” In its place, section 72 of the same Act provides that “A landlord under a lease of commercial premises may use the procedure in Schedule 12 (taking control of goods) to recover from the tenant rent payable under the lease.” In practice, an enforcement agent acting for the landlord can take control of goods at the premises, such as stock or equipment, after the required notice.
CRAR is limited to rent in the narrow sense. Section 76 of the 2007 Act defines rent as the amount payable under the lease for possession and use of the demised premises, together with interest on that amount and value added tax. It adds that rent “does not include any sum in respect of rates, council tax, services, repairs, maintenance, insurance or other ancillary matters”, whether or not the lease calls those sums rent. Where the lease does not separate the amount payable for possession and use, the Act takes so much of the total as is reasonably attributable to possession and use. For a shop tenant, the consequence is practical: an unpaid service charge or insurance rent for a closure period cannot, by itself, be recovered through CRAR. Unpaid rent can.
Section 77 of the 2007 Act adds conditions. The rent must have become due and payable before notice of enforcement is given, and it must be certain or capable of being calculated with certainty. The net unpaid rent must also reach a minimum amount at two moments: when notice of enforcement is given and when goods are first taken control of after that notice. In calculating the net unpaid rent, the landlord leaves out interest and value added tax and subtracts permitted deductions, which section 77(7) defines as “any deduction, recoupment or set-off that the tenant would be entitled to claim (in law or equity) in an action by the landlord for that rent”. If the lease validly excludes set-off, the tenant may have no deduction it could claim in an action for the rent, and so nothing to subtract under that subsection.
The minimum is set by the Taking Control of Goods Regulations 2013. Regulation 52(1), in the revised version read on 19 November 2026, fixes it at an amount equal to seven days’ rent, subject to higher thresholds that applied only during a relevant period defined by reference to the coronavirus legislation. On a rent of £73,000 a year, seven days’ rent is about £1,400. A tenant that deducts one day of closure from that rent does not, by that deduction alone, reach the threshold. A tenant that withholds a whole quarter, or deducts several weeks of disputed closure, plainly does.
The same regulations govern notice. Under regulation 6(1), as amended with effect from 1 May 2026 by S.I. 2026/366, notice of enforcement must be given to the debtor not less than fourteen clear days before the enforcement agent takes control of goods. Sundays, bank holidays, Good Friday and Christmas Day do not count when the period is calculated. The regulations allow an extension to twenty-eight clear days where a debt advice provider submits a request on the debtor’s behalf before the notice period expires, but that extension does not apply to debt classed as non-eligible business debt, a term defined by reference to the debt respite scheme. A business tenant should check that definition before relying on the longer period. The court may also order a shorter notice period if it is satisfied that goods are otherwise likely to be moved or disposed of to avoid enforcement.
The second tool is forfeiture. A lease may give the landlord a right of re-entry if rent remains unpaid for a stated number of days after it falls due. If the landlord brings proceedings in the county court to enforce that right for non-payment of rent, section 138 of the County Courts Act 1984 gives the tenant a structured way out. If the tenant pays into court or to the landlord, not less than five clear days before the return day, all the rent in arrear and the costs of the action, the action ceases and the tenant keeps the premises under the existing lease. That route is not available where the landlord is also relying on another ground of forfeiture or pursuing another claim in the same action. Otherwise, if the court finds that the landlord is entitled to forfeit, it orders possession at the end of a period of not less than four weeks unless the tenant pays the arrears and costs within that time, and it may extend that period. Even after the landlord has recovered possession following such an order, the tenant may apply for relief within six months of that recovery, and the court may grant relief on the terms it thinks fit.
Those protections are real, but they are not free. The tenant ends up paying the disputed rent, the costs of the action and its own legal costs, and spends weeks with its occupation in question. For a retailer with stock, staff and a fit-out in the unit, that is a heavy price for a deduction worth a few days’ rent. A tenant that disputes a closure period is usually better placed if it pays the sum demanded on time, records its objection in writing and pursues the dispute on the wording of the lease.
II. What can a retail tenant recover or negotiate after a closure?
A. Service charge, centre services and the evidence file
The service charge is where a closure most often produces a genuine argument. The statutory controls that residential tenants know do not help here. Section 18 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 defines a service charge, for the provisions of that Act that follow it, as an amount payable by a tenant of a dwelling for services, repairs, maintenance, improvements, insurance or the landlord’s costs of management, varying according to the relevant costs. A shop unit in a shopping centre is not a dwelling. The service charge of a retail tenant is therefore governed by the lease: by the services the landlord undertakes to provide, by the costs it may recover, by any requirement that costs be reasonable or properly incurred, and by the method used to share them between the units.
Start with the landlord’s obligations. A lease may oblige the landlord to keep the malls open during set hours, to light, heat and clean them, to provide security staff, to maintain lifts and escalators and to operate the car park. The obligation is often qualified. It may require the landlord to use reasonable endeavours, allow interruptions for repairs, emergencies or causes beyond its control, or permit the landlord to vary services in the interests of good estate management. A closure that falls within a qualification is unlikely to be a breach. A closure that does not, or a service that was not restored within a reasonable time, may give the tenant an argument about the service charge for that period or a claim for its loss, depending on the wording.
Next, look at the cost side. A closure can reduce some costs, such as cleaning or energy for the malls, and increase others, such as security, emergency repairs, specialist cleaning or additional management time. The lease decides whether those extra costs can pass through the service charge, whether they must first be recovered from an insurer or a third party, and whether a cost caused by the fault of one occupier should be charged to all. Ask for the budget, the year-end certificate and the supporting invoices that the lease allows the tenant to inspect, and compare the closure period with an ordinary month. If the lease provides for disputes to be referred to an independent surveyor or expert, note the time limits that apply.
The statutory definition of rent described above also matters here. Because section 76 of the 2007 Act excludes services, maintenance and insurance from the rent that CRAR can recover, a landlord seeking an unpaid service charge cannot use CRAR for it and has to look to its other remedies, such as a claim for the debt or the forfeiture provisions of the lease. That does not make it safe to withhold a disputed service charge: the lease may still treat it as rent for forfeiture purposes, and interest may run. It does mean the tenant should identify precisely which payment it disputes and why.
Whatever the dispute, it will be decided on evidence, and the best evidence is created during the closure, not months later. A retail tenant should keep:
- the notices, emails and messages received from the centre’s management, with the times they were sent;
- a log of the hours during which the unit could not be reached by customers, staff or deliveries;
- the till data for the closure period and for comparable days before it;
- staff rotas and wages paid for hours when no trading was possible;
- records of perishable stock lost or reduced in value;
- any written instruction received from the police, the fire service or another authority, if it was addressed to the tenant.
That file serves three purposes at once. It supports a request for a service charge adjustment, it substantiates an insurance claim and it gives the tenant a factual basis for any negotiation with the landlord.
B. Insurance claims and negotiating with the landlord
For lost trading, the first place to look is usually not the lease but the tenant’s own business interruption insurance. The landlord’s buildings and loss of rent insurance is arranged under the lease mainly for the landlord’s interest in the building and its rental income. Read the lease’s insurance clause alongside the rent suspension clause: the two are drafted separately, and the fact that the landlord insures against loss of rent does not by itself suspend the tenant’s covenant to pay. The tenant’s own policy is a different contract with different triggers.
A business interruption policy may respond primarily to damage at the insured premises. A closure of the shopping centre without damage to the unit may therefore fall outside the core cover. The question is whether the policy contains an extension that fits what happened. Look for wording dealing with denial of access, prevention of access, damage in the vicinity, action by the police or another public authority, or loss of attraction where damage to neighbouring property keeps customers away. Each extension has its own conditions: what must have caused the closure, how close the triggering event must be, whether a minimum period of interruption applies before cover begins, how long the indemnity period lasts and what sum is insured. Read the schedule as well as the policy booklet, because the schedule often shows which extensions were actually bought. Notify the insurer promptly and in the manner the policy requires, since a late notification can create an argument that has nothing to do with the merits.
Once a claim is made, the Insurance Act 2015 sets a standard for how it must be handled. Section 13A(1) provides that it is an implied term of every contract of insurance that, if the insured makes a claim, “the insurer must pay any sums due in respect of the claim within a reasonable time”. Section 13A(2) adds that “A reasonable time includes a reasonable time to investigate and assess the claim.” What is reasonable depends on the circumstances, including the type of insurance, the size and complexity of the claim, compliance with relevant statutory or regulatory rules or guidance, and factors outside the insurer’s control. If the insurer shows reasonable grounds for disputing the claim, it does not breach the implied term merely by not paying while the dispute continues, although its conduct in handling the claim may still be relevant. The remedies for breach, such as damages, are in addition to the right to enforce payment and to any interest. For a retailer, the practical lesson is to present a documented claim early, answer information requests quickly and keep a dated record of the insurer’s responses.
Negotiation with the landlord is the other route, and it is often the most effective one when the lease gives the tenant no clear right. A landlord may agree to a rent concession, a service charge credit or a deferral to keep a trading tenant in a centre. If it does, the agreement should be recorded in writing and signed for both parties. It should say which payments are affected and for which period, whether the concession is final or a deferral, how interest is treated, and whether it is conditional, for example on the tenant continuing to trade or paying the balance on time. Where a guarantor or a former tenant may still be liable under the lease, the agreement should deal with their position too, so that the change does not create a new dispute. A short exchange of emails that leaves these points open can be worse than no agreement at all.
The tenant’s request will carry more weight if it rests on the lease and on the evidence file. A request that identifies the clause relied on, the hours lost, the service charge items affected and the insurance position allows the landlord’s managing agent to answer on the merits. A request that simply announces a deduction invites a demand for the full rent and, if the deduction stands, the enforcement steps described in Part I.
Readers who also hold retail premises in France should note that French commercial lease law answers these questions with its own rules and remedies, and the same closure could be analysed differently under a lease governed by French real estate law. The method described here concerns leases governed by the law of England and Wales.
Conclusion
When a shopping centre closes, a retail tenant in England and Wales should begin with its lease. Rent remains due unless a clause suspends or reduces it, and a suspension clause triggered by damage from an insured risk does not cover a closure that involves no such damage. Deducting rent without that basis exposes the tenant to commercial rent arrears recovery once the net unpaid rent reaches seven days’ rent and after fourteen clear days’ notice, and to forfeiture proceedings with their costs. The service charge is governed by the lease rather than by the residential statutory regime, which makes the landlord’s service obligations, the cost provisions and a well-kept evidence file decisive. Lost trading is mainly an insurance question, governed by the wording of the tenant’s own policy and by the insurer’s duty to pay sums due within a reasonable time. Where the lease gives no right, a written agreement with the landlord is the safest way to share the cost of a closure.
Read also