The letter arrives in February, printed on the pale blue paper of the French tax administration. It demands 3 per cent of the full market value of your Dordogne farmhouse, every single year, for no reason other than the way you own it: through a société civile immobilière, the French non-trading property company universally known as an SCI. On a house valued at 480,000 euros the demand is 14,400 euros, repeated each January, and it lands on top of the taxe foncière, the yearly local property tax, and on top of any French income tax you already pay on rents. For British families who bought their French holiday home through an SCI before Brexit, or who still hold the shares of an English company that owns the villa outright, the shock is genuine, and the first instinct is to blame the United Kingdom’s departure from the European Union. The legal reality is narrower and, for once, more encouraging. The yearly 3 per cent charge set out in articles 990 D to 990 G of the French Tax Code, the Code général des impôts, predates Brexit by decades and catches French-owned structures too. But British owners are exposed in practice more often than French ones, because a company or property vehicle whose seat is in London can only escape the charge by telling the French tax office, every year, exactly who stands behind it, and a single inaccurate return is enough to lose the exemption altogether. This guide explains, in a first part, whether the charge catches your own structure and the three exits the statute leaves open, then, in a second part, how to file the yearly declaration correctly and how the French courts decide cases where the administration says you filed it wrong.
I. Whether the Yearly 3% Tax Catches Your British-Held French Home
A. Which British Vehicles the Tax Catches, From London Companies to Family SCIs
The starting point is the charging provision itself, and its wording is deliberately vast. Article 990 D of the French Tax Code provides that “Les entités juridiques : personnes morales, organismes, fiducies ou institutions comparables qui, directement ou par entité interposée, possèdent un ou plusieurs immeubles situés en France ou sont titulaires de droits réels portant sur ces biens sont redevables d’une taxe annuelle égale à 3 % de la valeur vénale de ces immeubles ou droits.” Article 990 D, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance. In ordinary English: every legal entity, company, body, trust or comparable institution that owns French property directly or through a chain, or that holds real rights such as a usufruct over French property, owes 3 per cent of the open-market value every year. The vehicle most British families use, the SCI, is caught as a matter of course. An SCI is a civil company within the meaning of the French Civil Code, which states that “Ont le caractère civil toutes les sociétés auxquelles la loi n’attribue pas un autre caractère à raison de leur forme, de leur nature, ou de leur objet.” Article 1845, Code civil, on Légifrance. It has no commercial character of its own, it is transparent enough for everyday family ownership, and precisely for that reason it sits squarely inside a charge that targets legal entities holding French bricks and mortar.
Three British configurations account for nearly every file the French courts see. The first is the English limited company that owns the villa directly, a structure chosen in the nineteen nineties and two thousands for privacy or for English succession reasons. The second is the French SCI whose shareholders live in Britain, often parents in Kent or Yorkshire with children as minority shareholders, which is the classic holiday-home arrangement. The third is the chain: a British holding company that owns the shares of a French SCI or a French property company, which itself owns the house. Chains do not dilute the tax; the statute looks straight through them. It provides that “est réputée posséder des biens ou droits immobiliers en France par entité interposée” every entity holding a participation of any form or size in the chain. Article 990 D on interposed entities, on Légifrance. A London holding company owning 100 per cent of a French SCI that owns a house in the Lot is therefore treated as owning that house itself, no matter how many companies sit between London and the property. Foundations and trusts are caught in the same way, as a Liechtenstein foundation owning a Riviera villa discovered when it litigated the charge all the way to the French Court of Cassation, the Cour de cassation, in May 2024. Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber, 10 May 2024, no. 21-11.230. If you are still choosing the ownership vehicle for a purchase, the companion guide to buying a French home through a family SCI describes the formation, tax and succession mechanics in detail. Buying a French home through a British family SCI.
Two practical consequences follow from this wide scope, and both surprise British owners. First, residence changes nothing about liability in principle: a British tax resident who holds shares in a French SCI, and a French tax resident who does the same, face the same yearly charge at the level of the entity, because the tax is levied by reference to the property and the entity, not by reference to where the shareholders sleep. Second, the amount is driven by the open-market value, the valeur vénale, of the whole property, not by the size of your shareholding and not by the profit the structure makes. A villa that has doubled in value since 2015 produces a bill that has doubled too, even if the SCI distributes nothing. That is why the exemptions matter so much, and why they turn almost entirely on paperwork filed on time.
B. The Three Exits From the Charge: Small Stakes, Treaty Seat and Yearly Disclosure
The statute does not leave owners without a way out. Article 990 E opens with the words “La taxe prévue à l’article 990 D n’est pas applicable” and then lists the entities the charge does not touch. Article 990 E, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance. For a British family, three exits are realistically available, and they should be tested in this order because the first two require no yearly filing at all. The first exit is size. An entity is outside the charge where its share of the French property is modest: the statute covers entities “Dont la quote-part du ou des immeubles situés en France ou des droits réels détenus directement ou indirectement portant sur ces biens est inférieure à 100 000” euros or to 5 per cent of the open-market value of those assets. Article 990 E, small-stake exemption, on Légifrance. A British investor holding a 3 per cent slice of a large French property company is therefore outside the tax entirely, while a family holding the whole of its own villa never is. A related shelter exists where the entity’s French bricks represent less than half of its French assets: the law exempts entities “Dont les actifs immobiliers, au sens de l’article 990 D, situés en France, représentent moins de 50 % des actifs français”. Article 990 E, below-half property assets, on Légifrance. That helps diversified groups, not the typical single-house SCI.
The second exit is the seat of the entity combined with the treaty network. The exemption reaches entities seated in France, in a European Union member state, or in a state that has signed an administrative assistance agreement with France for the fight against fraud and evasion, since the law requires a seat “dans un pays ou territoire ayant conclu avec la France une convention d’assistance administrative en vue de lutter contre la fraude et l’évasion fiscales”. Article 990 E, treaty-seat condition, on Légifrance. The United Kingdom signed a double tax treaty with France in 2008 that includes exchange-of-information machinery, which is why British-seated companies and SCIs are not shut out of the exemption the way entities in uncooperative jurisdictions are. But the treaty seat alone exempts nobody: it merely opens the door to the third exit, which is where British files are won and lost. That third exit is disclosure, and it comes in two alternative forms. Either the entity files every year, no later than 15 May, a return describing the property and naming every shareholder above 1 per cent, since the statute covers entities “Ou qui déclarent chaque année, au plus tard le 15 mai, au lieu fixé par l’arrêté prévu à l’article 990 F du présent code, la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles possédés au 1er janvier”. Article 990 E, yearly disclosure route, on Légifrance. Or the entity gives a standing undertaking to hand the same information to the tax office on request. The Court of Cassation confirmed in April 2026 that these are genuinely two alternative routes: entities “peuvent bénéficier d’une exonération totale sur le fondement du d du 3° de cet article si elles communiquent chaque année à l’administration fiscale certains renseignements ou si elles prennent et respectent l’engagement de communiquer à l’administration fiscale, sur sa demande, un certain nombre de renseignements”. Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber, 1 April 2026, Sweet Revenge Ltd, no. 25-10.605.
The Sweet Revenge case deserves attention because the taxpayer was a British company in exactly your position. Sweet Revenge Ltd, a company governed by the law of England, owned a property in the south of France and was assessed to the 3 per cent tax for the years 2007 to 2012. It had given an undertaking back in 2004: “Le 8 septembre 2004, la société a pris l’engagement de communiquer à l’administration fiscale, sur sa demande, les informations visées à l’article 990 E 3° d)”. Sweet Revenge Ltd, statement of facts, on the Court of Cassation website. It had also filed spontaneous yearly returns, yet those returns named four individuals as shareholders while the company had in fact been wholly owned by another company, Vinexsa International Limited, since 2006. The tax office reassessed, the appeal court in Aix-en-Provence upheld the bill, and the Court of Cassation dismissed the company’s appeal outright: “REJETTE le pourvoi”. Sweet Revenge Ltd, operative part, on the Court of Cassation website. The lesson for British shareholders is blunt. The Court accepted that filing voluntarily did not force the administration back into a special prior-request procedure, holding that “cette initiative avait permis à l’administration de notifier régulièrement une proposition de rectification”. Sweet Revenge Ltd, procedural holding, on the Court of Cassation website. Disclosure only protects you if the persons you disclose are the true owners. A parallel 2024 ruling against a Liechtenstein foundation shows the same strictness from the other side: where a structure genuinely has no individual holding more than 1 per cent, the administration cannot demand names that do not exist, but the entity must still prove the absence of tax fraud, and that foundation also lost. Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber, 10 May 2024, no. 21-11.230. Honest, exact disclosure is the whole game.
II. Filing the 15 May Return and Challenging a Wrong Bill
A. What British Families Declare Each Year, How the House Is Valued and the Wealth-Tax Overlap
Once you know the charge catches your structure and no automatic exemption applies, the yearly routine is fixed by article 990 F, and every step of it has a date or a person attached. The tax is assessed by reference to ownership on New Year’s Day: “La taxe est due à raison des immeubles ou droits immobiliers possédés au 1er janvier de l’année d’imposition”. Article 990 F, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance. Sell on 2 January and the seller still bears that year’s charge; buy on 2 January and the buyer waits a year. Where a chain of participations exists, the law places the debt as close to the bricks as possible: it is owed by the entity or entities nearest the property that are not themselves exempt, since the tax “sont les plus proches des immeubles ou droits immobiliers”. Article 990 F, closest-entity rule, on Légifrance. In the classic British arrangement, that means the French SCI itself is the taxpayer, even when every shareholder lives in Britain. And the shareholders are not bystanders: any intermediate person or trust between the taxpayer and the property “est solidairement responsable du paiement de cette taxe”, jointly liable for payment. Article 990 F, joint liability, on Légifrance. A London holding company above a French SCI can therefore be pursued for the SCI’s bill.
The return itself must “déclarer au plus tard le 15 mai de chaque année la situation, la consistance et la valeur des immeubles et droits immobiliers en cause”, a description, composition and value of the property, filed with payment at the office designated by ministerial order. Article 990 F, 15 May return, on Légifrance. In practice the filing is made on the dedicated 3 per cent form, historically the form 2746, which is also the vehicle for the shareholder disclosure that founds the exemption. Three details decide whether the return protects you. First, the value must be the genuine open-market value on 1 January, supported by comparable sales or a valuer’s note, because the administration compares declared values with its own databases and a low figure invites reassessment; the 2024 foundation case failed partly on valuation, the Court endorsing the values the administration had retained. Court of Cassation, 10 May 2024, no. 21-11.230, valuation point. Second, the persons named must be the true holders of more than 1 per cent of the shares or rights, at every level of the chain that the form requires, exactly as Sweet Revenge learned when its returns named individuals while a holding company owned everything. Third, the return must be filed even in a year when nothing changed: silence is treated as the absence of disclosure, and the exemption for that year is lost. Keep proof of filing and of payment every year, because five years later, in a dispute, the administration will ask you to produce them and the burden of showing proper disclosure sits with the entity claiming the exemption.
Two cost points complete the picture and both hurt. The 3 per cent is not deductible against income tax or corporation tax: “La taxe prévue à l’article 990 D n’est pas déductible pour l’assiette de l’impôt sur le revenu ou de l’impôt sur les sociétés.” Article 990 G, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance. It is a dead cost, not a credit. And it can sit alongside the French wealth tax on property, the impôt sur la fortune immobilière, universally called the IFI. The IFI catches individuals whose property assets exceed 1,300,000 euros: the statute makes liable those “Sont soumises à cet impôt, lorsque la valeur de leurs actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est supérieure à 1 300 000” euros. Article 964, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance. Its base expressly includes shares in companies and bodies established in or outside France, since it covers “Des parts ou actions des sociétés et organismes établis en France ou hors de France appartenant aux personnes mentionnées au 1° du présent article, à hauteur de la fraction de leur valeur représentative de biens ou droits immobiliers détenus directement ou indirectement par la société ou l’organisme”. Article 965, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance. A British shareholder of a French SCI holding a villa above the threshold therefore counts the shares in the IFI base while the SCI itself faces the 3 per cent, with no deduction of one from the other. Valuation for wealth purposes follows the death-duty rules, because “La valeur des actifs mentionnés à l’article 965 est déterminée suivant les règles en vigueur en matière de droits de mutation par décès”, and the well-known 30 per cent reduction applies only to the main home: “un abattement de 30 % est effectué sur la valeur vénale réelle de l’immeuble lorsque celui-ci est occupé à titre de résidence principale par son propriétaire”. Article 973, Code général des impôts, on Légifrance. A Dordogne holiday home held through an SCI never qualifies for that reduction. The combined arithmetic is what makes planning matter: on a 1.6 million euro second home, the family can face IFI at the shareholder level plus 48,000 euros of 3 per cent tax at the entity level in the same year, which is why getting the disclosure exemption right is worth far more than arguing about the valuation afterwards. For orientation on the British side of a move, the British government’s Living in France guidance collects the residence, healthcare and practical steps in one place. Living in France: British government guidance.
B. How French Judges Decide Challenges to the 3% Charge
When the tax office refuses the exemption and assesses the 3 per cent, the dispute follows the ordinary tax-litigation path, and the first forum is the administration itself. A taxpayer who considers the assessment wrong files a written claim, a réclamation, with the tax office, because claims of this kind belong to court-based litigation: the Book of Tax Procedures states that “Les réclamations relatives aux impôts, contributions, droits, taxes, redevances, soultes et pénalités de toute nature, établis ou recouvrés par les agents de l’administration, relèvent de la juridiction contentieuse”, and that the same courts hear claims seeking the benefit of a right granted by statute or regulation, since they cover claims “soit le bénéfice d’un droit résultant d’une disposition législative ou réglementaire”. Article L190, Livre des procédures fiscales, on Légifrance. The exemption under article 990 E is exactly such a statutory right, so a refusal can be taken to court after the administrative claim. For the 3 per cent, the competent court is the ordinary civil court, the tribunal judiciaire: Sweet Revenge assigned the administration before that court after its claim was rejected, and the Liechtenstein foundation and the Bois Dormant company litigated the same way. Recovery meanwhile follows the enforcement machinery of registration duties, because “La taxe est recouvrée selon les règles et sous les sanctions et garanties applicables aux droits d’enregistrement”. Article 990 F, recovery rules, on Légifrance. Interest and surcharges therefore accumulate while you argue, which is why files should be prepared as if for trial from the first letter.
The decided cases give British litigants three usable lessons, each drawn from a ruling described above. First, accuracy beats procedure. Sweet Revenge argued at length that the administration should have asked for explanations before reassessing, relying on the undertaking route and the special request procedure. The appeal court and the Court of Cassation disagreed: because the company had voluntarily filed yearly returns, that voluntary filing “cette initiative avait permis à l’administration de notifier régulièrement une proposition de rectification”, and the reassessment stood. Sweet Revenge Ltd, procedural holding, on the Court of Cassation website. A British company that files must file truthfully; a flawed voluntary return is worse than no return under the undertaking route, because it hands the administration the discrepancy in writing, as the mismatch between the four named individuals and the 100 per cent holding company showed. Second, proportionality arguments face a high wall. The foundation argued that taxing the full villa value to police fraud was excessive, and the courts answered that the charge, read with its exemptions, is proportionate to the aim of fighting fraud and evasion. Do not build a challenge on fairness alone; build it on the text of article 990 E and on proof. Third, procedure still matters at the margins. In July 2026 the Court of Cassation quashed an appeal decision in a 3 per cent dispute involving several million euros of assessments for the years 2009 to 2014, on a combination of appellate-procedure points and the scope of a published tax instruction, sending the case back rather than deciding the tax itself. Court of Cassation, Commercial Chamber, 8 July 2026, no. 25-12.737. The practical moral is that representation by counsel versed in French tax procedure pays for itself: limitation and admissibility points are unforgiving, and they are decided on the papers.
Concretely, a British family that receives an assessment or a refusal of exemption should work through four steps in order. Check the threshold maths first: if the entity’s share is genuinely below 100,000 euros or 5 per cent of the property value, the exemption needs no yearly return and the claim letter should say so with the valuation evidence attached. Then audit the chain on paper: list every company, SCI, trustee and individual between the house and the ultimate owners, with percentages at 1 January of each disputed year, and compare that chart line by line with what the filed returns actually said. Sweet Revenge lost on exactly this comparison. Then verify the seat and treaty position of each entity in the chain, because an entity outside the European Union and outside any assistance treaty cannot use the disclosure exits at all. Finally, file the administrative claim with the documents that prove each element, and prepare the court assignment in parallel, collecting the returns, the proof of filing, the shareholder registers, the valuations and the correspondence. The administration negotiates seriously only with complete files, and the tribunal judiciaire decides on documents, not on explanations given months later from memory.
Conclusion
The 3 per cent yearly charge is not a Brexit penalty, even if Brexit made it bite more British owners. It is a decades-old French anti-avoidance tax that presumes any entity holding French property is hiding its owners until the entity proves otherwise, once a year, in the form the statute prescribes. For a British family with a holiday home in an SCI, the entire planning collapses into one discipline: know whether your stake is below the 100,000 euro or 5 per cent shelter, and if it is not, file the 15 May disclosure naming the true holders of every slice above 1 per cent, at the true values, every year without exception. The Court of Cassation’s British-company ruling shows that courts forgive neither invented shareholders nor approximate values, and the foundation ruling shows they will not bend the text for sympathetic facts. Get the return right and the charge disappears by operation of law; get it wrong and the bill is 3 per cent of the whole house, undeductible, on top of the wealth tax, with interest running while you litigate. That is the order in which to read any letter from the tax office, and the order in which to answer it.
Read also
- Your French Company Needs Cash From Abroad: How to Increase Its Capital, Protect Control and File From Overseas
- You Live Abroad and Want to Sell Your Shares in Your French SAS: Approval, Transfer, Registration and Capital Gains Tax
- Your French Company Lost Half Its Capital While You Live Abroad: Rebuild Equity, Reduce Capital or Face Court-Ordered Dissolution