Kohen Avocats law firm · Paris

Insurance: What Can a Business Recover After a Late Part Payment?

Individuals, businesses and directors. Reda Kohen practises real estate law, company law and business law in Paris. First analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) – “Judilibre” and “Légifrance” Open Data databases.

Paris Bar Real estate, company and business law CNB listing on avocat.fr
Reda Kohen, lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar
Reda Kohen
Lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar
Insurance: What Can a Business Recover After a Late Part Payment?

By Reda Kohen, lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar

Insurance was a trending search in the United Kingdom. This article explains a general question of foreign law for a business insured under the law of England and Wales. When an insurer makes a part payment after a long investigation, how can the business separate the amount still owed under the policy from a loss caused by waiting for the money? The distinction matters when the business has borrowed to restart operations, paid a supplier to hold a repair slot or received a transfer whose accompanying letter is unclear about what it settles.

Section 13A of the Insurance Act 2015 requires an insurer to pay sums due within a reasonable time and expressly allows reasonable time to investigate and assess a claim. An outstanding balance alone does not establish breach. A genuine dispute about one part of a claim can leave a separate question about the timing of a different sum. The file therefore needs three records that can be reconciled: what was payable and on what evidence, what each transfer paid or extinguished, and what extra cost the business incurred because the money arrived late. The dates of those transfers can also affect the separate statutory time limit for a claim for damages.

I. Identify What the Part Payment Resolved

A. Match the Transfer to the Policy and the Claim File

Start by identifying the contract under which the insurer paid. A business may have a schedule covering buildings and stock, a separate business interruption section, an endorsement changing a limit and several versions of the wording. A bank statement gives the date and amount of a transfer. The remittance and correspondence are needed to see which policy and which part of the claim the transfer concerns. If a business has changed insurers, or renewed its cover since the incident, put the claims correspondence alongside the wording for the relevant insurance period. The document issued most recently is not necessarily the document governing the loss.

Check when the contract was entered into. Section 28 of the Enterprise Act 2016 inserted the implied term and confined the new Part 4A to contracts of insurance entered into after that Part came into force, and variations to those contracts. Section 44(3) of the Enterprise Act 2016 sets the commencement rule. The annotation to section 13A gives 4 May 2017 as the commencement date. With a long-running or repeatedly renewed policy, check the documents showing the agreement and any renewal. A loss or transfer occurring after that date does not by itself answer the contract-date question.

For each amount claimed, record the relevant cover, the quantified amount, any excess or limit the insurer relies on, and the documents that support the figure. On a commercial premises claim, the insurer might accept one invoice for emergency drying while asking for a revised estimate for the permanent works. The interruption claim may still depend on a comparison of trading records. A single total in a spreadsheet conceals the different reasons why those amounts are at different stages. Show the separate positions as of each payment date, including figures accepted only as estimates.

The transfer can carry several signals. An insurer may call it an advance against building works, describe it as a payment of an agreed stock value, or propose a settlement of specified claims in return for acceptance. Preserve the original correspondence, any reply or signed agreement, the reference shown on the transfer and the evidence of receipt. Where the documents leave the allocation uncertain, the file should show the uncertainty. A useful reconciliation identifies the amount allocated by the documents, the possible outstanding policy items, and the amounts whose legal status still needs to be resolved.

Keep deductions visible as well. If a repair invoice is for £45,000, the insurer pays £30,000 and identifies a £5,000 excess, the remaining £10,000 still needs an explanation. It may be disputed scope, an amount held back pending evidence, or part of the invoice that falls outside the terms. The gap between the invoice and the bank credit does not by itself establish which explanation is correct. The applicable clause, the insurer’s calculation and the repair specification help determine whether there is any balance due. The same records make it easier to explain why the accepted amount could have been assessed earlier, if that is what the correspondence shows.

A company may receive one bulk transfer covering several locations. In that setting, a useful reconciliation has one row for each combination of policy, location and item. Record the insurer’s allocation where it exists and use a separate row for any amount still unallocated. If the business’s accountant has booked the money against one location for convenience, keep that accounting entry distinct from the evidence of the insurer’s agreement. The business may need to revisit the allocation when deciding which covered sum was still unpaid at a given date.

B. Reconstruct the Investigation for Each Outstanding Amount

Section 13A(2) gives the insurer a reasonable period to investigate and assess the claim. Section 13A(3) makes the assessment depend on all relevant circumstances. The provision identifies the type of insurance, the size and complexity of the claim, compliance with relevant statutory or regulatory rules or guidance, and factors outside the insurer’s control as possible considerations. The statute gives a framework for examining the file. It does not supply one number of days for all property and interruption claims.

A useful chronology begins when the business made the claim under the contract. Record the first submission and each substantial change in the material available to the insurer. Add the dates when a request for information arrived and when the business met it. Distinguish a request that was answered in full from one answered provisionally. For a delayed survey, record who arranged access, whether the site could safely be inspected, and when the report became available. An apparently quiet period in an email chain can correspond to work on an inspection or testing that the other party had good reason to await.

Classify the delays by the work they prevented. An unavailable stock count may affect stock valuation; it may have little bearing on the amount of an agreed emergency repair invoice. If an insurer asked for the same material twice, compare the requests and the responses. The second request may have identified an actual gap, or it may have repeated a question already answered with a dated document. Record the difference with the attachment and correspondence, rather than relying on a description written months later. Where an item was approved in principle, separate that approval from agreement on the amount or the date of payment.

Under section 13A(4), an insurer that shows reasonable grounds for disputing whether anything is payable, or how much is payable, does not breach the implied term merely by leaving the claim or affected part unpaid while that dispute continues. The provision also makes claims handling relevant to whether and when a breach occurred. A business can therefore record both the grounds given for the dispute and how the insurer dealt with them. The contemporaneous file should show when the insurer raised a reservation, what material it relied on, whether it revised its position after receiving an answer, and whether the reservation actually concerned the amount withheld.

Consider a hypothetical business with two separate claimed costs. The insurer accepts the need for temporary repairs, receives a fixed invoice and confirms the approved amount. It also disputes whether interruption cover responds during a period when an independent supplier could not deliver. That second question could warrant further investigation while the first is ready for payment. To evaluate the first amount, identify what evidence made the relevant dates, liability and figure assessable. The example does not presume that the policy requires advances in every case. Whether a distinct sum was due, and whether the investigation time was reasonable, remain questions about the wording and evidence.

The same exercise can reveal genuine problems with the insured’s own chronology. A business may have sent a summary of profit figures early but supplied underlying accounts much later. It may have approved a contractor’s work before getting the only invoice that separated insured repairs from improvements. Keep those events in the file. They can explain why a proposed date for reasonable payment needs to move. A credible presentation identifies which periods remain open to argument and how the loss estimate changes if a later date is used.

II. Measure the Delay Loss and Check the Filing Date

A. Tie Each Additional Cost to Money That Arrived Late

Section 13A(5) distinguishes remedies for breach of the implied term, including damages, from enforcement of sums due under the policy and from any right to interest on those sums. Use separate columns for the underlying policy balance, any interest being considered and the loss said to result from late payment. For instance, the invoice for restoring damaged machinery may belong in the policy claim. The finance charge on a facility drawn to pay that invoice while the insurer withheld an amount due is a different item to investigate. Recording the charge does not establish that it is recoverable. The dates, the need to borrow and the relationship to the particular unpaid sum all need evidence.

Build two dated accounts of the cash flow. In the first, record what happened, including expenditure, revenue available for the repair, credit drawn, and each payment received from the insurer. In the second, use a supportable date for when the amount due could reasonably have been paid. Change the entries that genuinely depend on that payment. Keep the market conditions, existing borrowing and costs that the business would have incurred anyway in both accounts. The difference is a way to identify the amount to examine, subject to the terms and the evidence.

Suppose a business funded repairs with a £60,000 draw and later received £40,000 from the insurer. The draw may include an upgrade paid by the business and costs still in dispute. Treating interest on the full £60,000 as a single delay loss can overstate the effect of the timing of the insurance money. Trace the relevant part of the draw to the expenditure, show how the transfer changed the balance, and use the actual loan statement to calculate the interest for the applicable period. If the business had drawn money earlier for another project, distinguish the cost of that existing debt from any additional finance cost attributable to the payment delay.

A supplier charge may call for a different comparison. A contractor may have reserved a date contingent on receipt of a deposit, then quoted a higher price when the business sought the same work later. Keep both quotations, their validity terms, the original deposit requirement and evidence about alternative suppliers or dates. The difference in price may reflect the timing of the funds, a change in the works, broader price movements or several factors together. If the later work includes extra repairs or changes in specification, isolate them before comparing the prices.

Lost trading can be especially difficult to isolate. For a business that remained shut after damage, the entire period of closure is rarely a meaningful starting figure for delay loss. Break the period into stages. Ask when the premises could be used safely, when the replacement equipment was available, when the supplier could have begun work, and how those events relate to a payment arriving on a different date. Signed orders, job schedules and contemporaneous cancellations are more informative than a later statement that business would have returned immediately. An unavoidable closure and a further period plausibly linked to lack of funds can appear in the same accounts as separate periods.

When the insurer makes more than one transfer, revise the counterfactual at each transfer. If a first payment gives the business enough cash to start repairs but leaves it needing finance for a later milestone, the continuing cost may be smaller than before. If an earlier payment would have made no difference because access remained blocked, keep that period out of the comparison until the evidence supports a change. If money was diverted to meet wages or an existing liability, record why and what other funds were available. A calculation presented with its inputs can be tested even where the parties disagree over the date or amount.

A finance file is only as useful as its supporting records. Keep statements showing interest actually debited, supplier notices identifying the reason for a fee, and internal approvals showing when a commitment was made. Attach the document to the particular line it supports. Where the numbers come from forecasts, show the assumptions, including sales that might have been made at another site or recovered later. A dated calculation can accompany the evidence from the claims file and be updated without changing the underlying documents. The wider distinction between insurance proceeds and trading loss also arises in commercial contracts and business disputes.

B. Read the Contract Terms and Track the Payment That Clears the Sums Due

Check any policy term that changes the insurer’s liability for paying late. For non-consumer insurance, section 16A of the Insurance Act 2015 makes a term ineffective to the extent that it puts the insured in a worse position in respect of a deliberate or reckless breach. In the section’s definition, that means the insurer knew it was in breach or did not care whether it was. A protracted delay can require investigation without proving either state of mind. For other matters within section 13A, a disadvantageous term can take effect only if the statutory transparency requirements specified in section 16A(4) have been met.

Section 17 of the Insurance Act 2015 requires sufficient steps to draw the disadvantageous term to the insured’s attention before the contract or variation is agreed. It also requires clear and unambiguous wording as to the term’s effect. The characteristics of insureds of that kind and the circumstances of the transaction matter. Under section 17(5), actual knowledge of the term by the insured or its agent when the contract or variation was agreed prevents reliance on a failure to meet the requirement in section 17(2). It remains useful to recover the quotation, covering emails, endorsements and accessible versions of the wording from the placement file.

Read a settlement on its own terms. Section 16A(6) excludes a contract settling a claim arising under an insurance contract from the scope of that section. If a transfer is accompanied by settlement correspondence, identify the claim the parties intended to settle and the words they used about other amounts or liabilities. A remittance for a described policy amount presents a different evidential question from a signed settlement of a defined dispute. Keep the final agreed terms and all schedules together. Where the only surviving record is a payment reference saying final, the reference should be considered with the exchange that preceded it.

There is a specific time limit in England and Wales. Section 5A of the Limitation Act 1980 provides that an action for breach of the section 13A implied term may not be brought after one year from the date on which the insurer paid all the sums referred to in section 13A(1). Section 5A(2) treats a payment extinguishing liability to pay one of those sums as payment of that sum for this purpose. The question is what the payment satisfied. The amount that reached the business and the liability extinguished may need separate entries on the reconciliation.

Take a hypothetical policy under which a £30,000 advance is received and a remaining sum due is paid two months later. On those assumptions, the first transfer alone is not payment of all the sums due. If the first transfer instead extinguished liability for the only sum due, its date can be important even if the business continues to pursue damages for delay. And if every amount actually due was satisfied by an early payment, the later exchange of claim correspondence is not the statutory trigger under section 5A. In each example, an outstanding figure in the business’s own spreadsheet is evidence of a position taken. Whether that figure was due depends on the underlying policy and the facts.

Treat the one-year rule as additional. Section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980 generally bars an action founded on simple contract after six years from accrual of the cause of action. Section 5A adds a distinct limit for the late-payment claim. A business should record possible dates for accrual and for payment of all sums due as separate entries. A late transfer does not automatically extend a period otherwise applicable to the action. A disagreement about whether payment was complete is a reason to examine the earliest supportable date, alongside any alternative date and the documents that explain the difference.

On a claim involving several payments, a dated allocation agreed by both sides can clarify which liability each payment discharged. Suppose the insurer and insured agree that a building payment settles building work but reserve their positions on insured stock. Keep the words defining that reservation with the payment record. If the insurer later takes the position that the stock was never covered, the earlier settlement and the coverage question may both matter to the date analysis. A reservation does not establish that additional money was due. The value of the record is that it lets someone reconstruct each party’s position without inferring the scope of the settlement from the order in which money moved.

Use the date register to join up the legal and commercial work. For each plausible payment date, record the transfer, any accompanying settlement, the covered amount it concerned and any sum that might still be due. Keep the policy balance separate from the claimed damages so that a continuing dispute over financing charges is visible as a different question. If the insured and insurer disagree over the last remaining policy item, show how each position would affect the one-year analysis. The file should identify the unresolved issue explicitly, so that an assumed start date cannot pass unnoticed into a decision about the claim.

Conclusion

A business can assess a late part payment by bringing three records together. The policy and investigation file show which sums were due and what time was reasonably needed to assess them. The remittance and settlement documents show what each transfer satisfied. The business records show which additional costs can be traced to waiting for a payable amount. Where the parties disagree about the remaining balance, the reasonableness of the investigation or the cause of a cost, the conclusion on damages remains dependent on that evidence. Keep both possible accrual dates and the possible date on which all sums due were paid in view when assessing the time available.

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

What our clients say

4,9212 Google reviews
kader ladjouzi
1 month ago

Best real estate law and business law lawyer in Paris. A humane and attentive lawyer, with a wonderful team. Thank you, Maître KOHEN

Translated from French

Janou SAMUEL
2 months ago

Thank you to Maître KOHEN for his analyses of recent case law on fraudulent non-disclosure in property sales. It reassures me about an action for annulment that I am considering after buying a house affected by serious defects intentionally concealed by the seller and not reported by the estate agent; also defects (rising damp) characterised by spreading through-cracks and damp stains, not reported by the estate agent… Worse, defects concealed by the latter or at his instigation, under a coat of paint and by polystyrene tiles glued to the ceiling of a bedroom. And the said estate agent drafted the preliminary contract, which of course contains no information about any of these defects. Just to add that, being 77 years old and suffering from cognitive impairment, I am certain that the estate agent thought I would not be able to discover the deception and above all to establish the fraudulent intent, still less to bring legal proceedings given the complexity and length of the procedure... That is why I am opting for the criminal route, insofar as the intentional concealment of the defects by the seller and then by the estate agent amounts to the fraudulent manoeuvres of art. 313-1 of

Translated from French

Paul MALIK (powlo)
5 months ago

Maître Reda KOHEN assisted me in a dispute concerning a sale agreement with a defaulting party. He provided professional and responsive support, and I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

Rayan Kallout
6 months ago

I highly recommend Maître Reda Kohen. Thanks to his explanations, I was able to recover my security deposit in a situation that seemed blocked. He was responsive, clear, and very professional. A big thank you for his invaluable help!

Translated from French

Naji Jouahri
6 months ago

Excellent support from Maître Kohen in a case combining business law and real estate law. Clear legal analysis from the first meeting, right through to the hearing. Professional and accessible lawyer, I highly recommend his firm in Paris 17.

Translated from French

Halim Tunde
6 months ago

Maître Kohen assisted me in recovering unpaid debts from a defaulting tenant. Procedure mastered from start to finish, from the payment order to eviction. Human, attentive, and always reachable. Thank you for your work.

Translated from French

Cha
6 months ago

As a young student living in an apartment, my landlord tried to make me leave my accommodation even though he had sent me no termination notice. I therefore contacted Mr. Reda Kohen to help me as I couldn’t handle the situation alone. In just 3 days everything was resolved, Maître Kohen defended me and accompanied me with an irreproachable level of commitment and efficiency. I can only recommend his professionalism!

Translated from French

Asmaa Maazaz
8 months ago

I turned to Maître Kohen for a complex real estate dispute and I highly recommend his firm. He is very professional; he thoroughly analyzed my case from the very first appointment and clearly explained the possible options. Thanks to his expertise, we achieved a very favorable outcome. Responsive, a good teacher, and committed, he is a lawyer you can truly trust. Yours faithfully, Miss Maazaz

Translated from French

chaymaa aouadi
8 months ago

I called upon Maître Reda Kohen, a real estate lawyer in Paris, and I am fully satisfied with his support. Very professional, responsive and attentive. He quickly analyzed my case, clearly explained the legal strategy and effectively defended my interests. Thanks to his expertise and determination, we obtained a very favorable outcome. I highly recommend Maître Kohen to anyone looking for a real estate lawyer in Paris.

Translated from French

Fatima Arbouhi
8 months ago

Excellent real estate lawyer. Professional, responsive and attentive, he perfectly met my expectations and accompanied me with great seriousness throughout my case. I highly recommend his services.

Translated from French

Laurent Joulaud
9 months ago

Maître Kohen helped us enormously in our case of eviction of a tenant who hadn't paid rent for many months. He was quick and efficient in drafting the summons and the various actions. He was also very clear about the different stages of the procedure and gave us almost instant feedback when he received documents to communicate. I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

H
9 months ago

The best real estate lawyer in Paris, I recommend without hesitation.

Translated from French

Sokona Dembele
9 months ago

Maître Kohen is an extremely competent and rigorous lawyer. His professionalism, responsiveness, and the quality of his support were remarkable—I weigh my words. Thanks to serious and perfectly mastered work, we obtained a favorable outcome despite a delicate case. He is the best real estate lawyer. I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

Hamid Agouz
1 month ago

I was pleasantly surprised by the responsiveness of Mr Reda Cohen, who took the time to answer my questions about my case instantly. It has become so rare these days to find a lawyer who is so available, responsive and attentive, even when it is simply a matter of answering questions. His answers are clear, precise and reassuring. You can tell that he takes the time to understand the situation and to provide relevant answers. Beyond his excellent ratings on Google, it is above all this availability and this seriousness that make the difference. Many thanks to Mr Reda Cohen for his professionalism and his responsiveness. I highly recommend!

Translated from French

Salon Sisters
1 month ago

Thank you, Maître Kohen, for your professionalism, your responsiveness and your seriousness. You handled my case perfectly, with a great deal of attentiveness, rigour and efficiency. I was very satisfied with your support and the work carried out. I recommend him without hesitation!

Translated from French

Frederic Lopes
1 month ago

Excellent professional. I strongly recommend him for his dedication and expertise.

Translated from French

Mitalie Talie
1 month ago

Great business law lawyer in Paris, attentive, available and understanding. I would come back if I have a problem.

Translated from French

Siko7801 rouger
1 month ago

Thank you for this very humane and professional advice. I strongly recommend.

Translated from French

Coralie Natation
1 month ago

I highly recommend Maître Kohen’s firm for its availability, its responsiveness and its very great professionalism. Thank you for the many pieces of advice and the efficiency of your firm!

Translated from French

Amir
8 months ago

Excellent expertise in real estate law from Me Reda Kohen

Translated from French

Beaudrique Abao
1 month ago
Krep Events Traiteur Breton
1 month ago

very clear article

Translated from French

Zakaria Airbnb
1 month ago
Gabriele
1 month ago