Kohen Avocats law firm · Paris

British Early Retiree in France After Brexit: Joining PUMA, Paying the CSM Health Levy and Challenging a Wrong Bill

Individuals, businesses and directors. Reda Kohen practises real estate law, company law and business law in Paris. First analysis: €80 incl. VAT, personal reply within 24 hours.

100% confidential · Legal professional privilege · No obligation

Article generated by artificial intelligence, through a process designed and supervised by the firm

Source: French Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) – “Judilibre” and “Légifrance” Open Data databases.

Paris Bar Real estate, company and business law CNB listing on avocat.fr
Reda Kohen, lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar
Reda Kohen
Lawyer admitted to the Paris Bar
British Early Retiree in France After Brexit: Joining PUMA, Paying the CSM Health Levy and Challenging a Wrong Bill

You are 58, you have sold the house in Kent, and the removal van is booked for the Dordogne. You do not work any more, you will not draw your United Kingdom State Pension for another eight years, and nobody in Whitehall is going to hand you an S1 form. The French house is ready, the visa file is nearly complete, and one question keeps you awake: who pays if you fall ill in France, and how do you get into the French health system in the first place? This article answers that question for the British early retiree living in France after Brexit. It explains how the Protection universelle maladie, universally known as PUMA, the French residence-based gateway into state healthcare, takes in an inactive British resident, and it explains the price that often follows a year later, the cotisation subsidiaire maladie, the CSM, the yearly health levy collected from people who live in France off capital income rather than wages. It closes with the practical route for challenging a refusal of cover or a wrongly calculated bill, using the statutes exactly as they stand and the recent court decisions that apply them.

I. How a British early retiree with no job joins the French health system after Brexit

Since the end of the Brexit transition period, a British citizen who settles in France is a third-country national. That single fact shapes everything about healthcare. There is no automatic cover, no European Health Insurance Card that settles a resident, and no National Health Service backstop once France becomes home. Cover has to be built, step by step, inside the French system, and the foundation of that system is one short statutory promise. Article L. 160-1 of the Social Security Code provides: “Toute personne travaillant ou, lorsqu’elle n’exerce pas d’activité professionnelle, résidant en France de manière stable et régulière bénéficie, en cas de maladie ou de maternité, de la prise en charge de ses frais de santé dans les conditions fixées au présent livre.” In plain English, anyone who works in France, or who lives there in a stable and lawful way without working, is entitled to have health costs covered. The early retiree falls squarely into the second branch of that sentence, but each word of it, stable, lawful, resident, has to be proved.

A. Proving lawful and stable residence in France

Stability comes first because it is the condition most newcomers underestimate. Article R. 111-2 of the Social Security Code treats as stably resident “les personnes qui ont leur foyer ou le lieu de leur séjour principal sur le territoire métropolitain, en Guadeloupe, en Guyane, à la Martinique, à La Réunion, à Saint-Barthélemy ou à Saint Martin”, provided that residence has a permanent character. The foyer, the home in the everyday sense, or the main place of stay, is what counts, and the test looks at real life rather than declarations: where the furniture is, where the family sleeps, where the retiree actually spends the year. The official service-public.fr guidance for PUMA draws the practical consequence for people without a job: once in France, they wait three months before rights open, and those rights then stay open where the person lives in France for at least six months of the year. The six-month warning matters enormously to British households that split the year between France and the United Kingdom, because a thirteen-week winter in the Dordogne and nine months in Surrey does not build a French foyer.

The three-month wait is not administrative guidance. It is a decree-level rule, and it is enforced. Article D. 160-2 of the Social Security Code states: “Les personnes qui demandent à bénéficier de la prise en charge des frais de santé en application des dispositions de l’article L. 160-5 doivent produire un justificatif démontrant qu’elles résident en France de manière ininterrompue depuis plus de trois mois”. Proof of more than three months of uninterrupted residence, or proof of belonging to one of the narrowly listed exemption categories, is compulsory. The Cour de cassation has given that rule its full weight in a case about a foreign national refused affiliation. In its judgment of 3 June 2021, appeal number 20-10.687, published in the Bulletin, the Second Civil Chamber held that a person who “peuvent produire un justificatif démontrant qu’elle résident en France de manière ininterrompue depuis plus de trois mois ou qu’elles relèvent de l’une des catégories qu’il énumère limitativement” states the only two doors into the system, and it rejected the argument that applying the rule to a foreigner was discriminatory. The Court recalled that the provisions “s’appliquent sans distinction de nationalité à toute personne qui, n’exerçant pas d’activité professionnelle, peut bénéficier, en cas de maladie ou de maternité, de la prise en charge de ses frais de santé par l’assurance maladie”, and found no breach of the European Convention on Human Rights. The full decision is published at Cour de cassation, Second Civil Chamber, 3 June 2021, number 20-10.687. For the British early retiree the message is blunt: arrive in January, and the earliest possible opening of rights is April, and private cover has to bridge the gap.

Lawfulness, the second half of the statutory test, is where Brexit bites. The service-public.fr PUMA page states the rule plainly: nationals of the European Economic Area and Switzerland move and reside freely with an identity card or passport, while nationals of any other country must hold a titre ou document de séjour, a residence title or residence document. Since 2021 the British passport no longer opens the first door, so the retiree proves lawfulness with a Withdrawal Agreement residence card, the WARP card, for those who were already settled before the end of 2020, or with a long-stay visa followed by a carte de séjour, a residence permit, for those who arrived later, most often the long-stay visitor visa for inactive households. The British government’s own healthcare guidance for France confirms the sequence from the other side of the Channel: in some cases proof of healthcare cover must be shown before registering as a resident or when applying for a visa, and, for those who do not qualify for an S1, the route is a direct application to the French system, since the guidance sends applicants to their local CPAM office to apply for PUMA, the CPAM being the Caisse primaire d’assurance maladie, the local health insurance fund that manages each insured person’s file. The guidance is published at Healthcare in France on gov.uk, and the service-public.fr procedure page sits at Protection universelle maladie (Puma) on service-public.fr.

B. Applying to the CPAM and reacting when the answer is no or never comes

The application goes to the CPAM of the place of residence, on the standard opening-of-rights form referenced as procedure R45084 on service-public.fr, with identity documents, the residence permit, proof of address, and, crucially, the evidence that three months of uninterrupted presence have already run. Early retirees should assemble that proof from day one: the dated visa stamp, the lease or completion deed, utility contracts in the applicant’s name, and bank statements showing everyday spending in France. The fund examines whether each cumulative condition is met, and a thin file is the most common cause of delay, because the CPAM cannot open rights on promises about future residence.

When the answer is negative, or when months pass without an answer, the retiree is not at the end of the road. Every one of the recent court decisions studied for this article travelled the same ladder: an internal friendly-appeal challenge before the commission de recours amiable, the CRA, the fund’s own review commission, then a case before the social division of the judicial court, the pôle social du tribunal judiciaire, and then the court of appeal. That ladder is the ordinary route for affiliation and contribution disputes alike. Two practical points decide whether it works. First, every notice carries short and strict time limits, printed on the decision itself, and they must be diaried the day the letter arrives, because a late challenge fails whatever its merits. Second, the challenge must attack the exact ground of the refusal with documents, not generalities: a missing three-month proof is cured by dated evidence of presence, a dispute about the foyer is answered with the lease, tax notices and school or medical registrations, and a question about the residence permit is answered with the permit itself or the prefecture receipt.

There is also a right worth knowing for the household that retires after working in France. Article L. 161-8 of the Social Security Code provides for a maintien, a carrying-over mechanism: people who stop meeting the work-related conditions for affiliation to the health, maternity, invalidity and death risks of the scheme they belonged to, but who still satisfy the residence conditions and have not newly qualified elsewhere, keep their cash-benefit rights for a period set by decree. In other words, the British employee who works in Lyon, is affiliated through that work, and then retires in place keeps cash-benefit rights while continuing to satisfy the residence conditions, which smooths the handover from worker status to PUMA. And there is a warning that cuts the other way: the service-public.fr page recalls that anyone who deliberately refuses to join a compulsory scheme, or who persistently avoids taking the steps toward compulsory affiliation, faces six months of imprisonment and a 15,000 euro fine. Sitting outside the system on the assumption that a United Kingdom-issued card for temporary stays will do is not a strategy.

II. The price of PUMA for people living off capital: the CSM levy and how to fight it

Roughly a year after affiliation, many early retirees receive a letter they never expected: a demand from URSSAF, the Union de recouvrement des cotisations de sécurité sociale et d’allocations familiales, the network of funds that collects social contributions, claiming several thousand euros under the heading cotisation subsidiaire maladie. The CSM is the financial counterpart of PUMA for people who consume healthcare without contributing through work. It falls precisely on the household that lives in France on dividends, rental income, savings interest and capital gains rather than on a salary, which is the textbook position of the British early retiree. Understanding who pays, on what base, and how the courts treat challenges to the bill is the second half of this article.

A. Who pays the CSM and how the 6.5 per cent bill is worked out

The charge is defined by Article L. 380-2 of the Social Security Code, which opens with the principle: “Les personnes mentionnées à l’article L. 160-1 sont redevables d’une cotisation annuelle lorsqu’elles remplissent les conditions suivantes”. The two conditions that follow are cumulative. First, professional income earned in France during the year must sit below a threshold set by decree: “Leurs revenus tirés, au cours de l’année considérée, d’activités professionnelles exercées en France sont inférieurs à un seuil fixé par décret.” Where the person is married or bound by a civil solidarity pact, the PACS, the French registered partnership, the other partner’s French professional income is tested against the same threshold. Second, the person must have received no retirement or invalidity pension, no annuity, and no unemployment benefit during the year: “Elles n’ont perçu ni pension de retraite ou d’invalidité, ni rente, ni aucun montant d’allocation de chômage au cours de l’année considérée”, again tested on both members of a married or PACS couple. The British early retiree who genuinely lives off capital, with no pension yet in payment and no French earnings, passes both gates straight into the charge, while the retiree who already draws any retirement pension, British or French, sits outside it and must organise cover on the pensioner track instead.

The base of the charge is capital income. The statute continues: the charge is assessed on a base made up of property income, investment income, capital gains on disposals of assets or rights of any kind, and non-professional business profits, all measured through the definitions of article 1417, IV of the Tax Code. That is why the household, investment income, capital gains on disposals of assets or rights of any kind, and non-professional business profits, all measured through the definitions of article 1417, IV of the Tax Code, feed the assessment, which is why the household living off a buy-to-let portfolio and a share account feels the levy most directly.

The arithmetic is set by Article D. 380-1 of the Social Security Code: “Montant de la cotisation = 6,5 % × (A-0,5 × PASS) × [1-R/ (0,2 × PASS)]”. Three quantities drive the result. A is the capital income base just described, capped at eight times the PASS, the plafond annuel de la sécurité sociale, the yearly social-security ceiling that is revalued each year. Half of one PASS is subtracted from that base before the 6.5 per cent rate bites, which shelters modest capital income entirely. R is professional income, and the final bracket scales the bill down as professional income rises, reaching zero where earnings cross the threshold, so that the levy genuinely targets only those who contribute little or nothing through work. Where the person meets the PUMA conditions for only part of the calendar year, for example the household that arrives in September, “le montant de la cotisation due est calculé au prorata de cette partie de l’année”, the bill is calculated pro rata for that part of the year. Retirees who already hold a United Kingdom S1 because they have started drawing a United Kingdom State Pension stand outside this machinery altogether, since the United Kingdom then funds their French healthcare, which is why the companion question of pensioner status, covered in the firm’s earlier analysis of the S1 route at British state pensioners, the S1 and French healthcare, should be checked before any CSM figure is accepted.

Timing completes the picture. Article R. 380-4 of the Social Security Code provides: “La cotisation mentionnée à l’article L. 380-2 est appelée au plus tard le dernier jour ouvré du mois de novembre de l’année suivant celle au titre de laquelle elle est due. Elle est exigible dans les trente jours suivant la date à laquelle elle est appelée.” The levy for a given year is therefore called by the last working day of November of the following year at the latest, and becomes payable within thirty days of the call. The same article adds a practical safety valve for the retiree who spots an error: a person who considers that the called amount does not exactly reflect their situation or income “peut s’acquitter du montant de la cotisation dont il estime être redevable sur la base de tout élément probant qu’il communique à l’organisme chargé du recouvrement”, meaning they may pay the amount they believe they truly owe, supported by any convincing evidence sent to the collecting body, which must then examine the file.

B. Challenging the URSSAF demand step by step

The first step is verification, not protest. The demand must be tested line by line: is the year right, is the person named the right taxpayer, was any pension, annuity or unemployment benefit received that year by either spouse, which would take the household out of the charge entirely, do the income figures match the tax return, was the arrival-year pro rata applied, and was the couple test correctly carried out where only one partner has earnings? Any one of these points can move the bill by thousands of euros, and the collecting body works from automated tax data that does not always know that a pension started, that a couple separated, or that residence began mid-year.

The second step is to understand what a late demand is worth, because URSSAF calls frequently arrive after the November target. Three recent court of appeal decisions give a consistent and sobering answer, and each of them concerned an individual in exactly the early-retiree position, affiliated to PUMA and billed on capital income. On 24 November 2023 the Paris Court of Appeal, ruling in case RG 20/04763, upheld in full a CSM call issued on 15 December 2017 for the year 2016, in an amount exceeding sixteen thousand euros, with a formal notice, the mise en demeure, the formal demand to pay that starts enforcement, following in 2019. The court recalled the Cour de cassation’s settled position that “le non-respect par l’organisme de recouvrement de la date limite mentionnée par l’article R. 380-4 a pour seul effet de reporter le délai au terme duquel la cotisation devient exigible”, so that missing the November deadline merely postpones the date from which the contribution becomes payable and from which late surcharges run, and it found no nullity where no statute provides for nullity. The decision is published at Paris Court of Appeal, 24 November 2023, RG 20/04763. On 27 June 2025 the same court, in case RG 22/01239, declared lawful, “DÉCLARE régulier”, a CSM call of 15 December 2017 for 8,170 euros, validated the August 2019 formal notice, ordered payment of the full amount, and dismissed the insured person’s claim for reimbursement of private health insurance taken out while disputing cover. That decision is published at Paris Court of Appeal, 27 June 2025, RG 22/01239. On 17 February 2026 the Metz Court of Appeal, in case RG 23/00769, declared lawful, “DECLARE REGULIERS”, two CSM calls issued in November 2018 for 2016 and 2017, at 3,541 euros and 1,732 euros, validated a December 2019 formal notice for the 5,273 euro total, and confirmed the friendly-appeal commission’s rejection. That decision is published at Metz Court of Appeal, 17 February 2026, RG 23/00769. The lesson for the British retiree is direct: a demand that arrives in December instead of November, or long after the year in question, is not void for that reason alone, and the argument must be built on the base, the status and the figures instead.

The third step is the procedure itself. As in affiliation disputes, the demand is first contested before the commission de recours amiable, then before the social division of the judicial court, with appeal to the cour d’appel. The three decisions above each recite that exact path, including review by the friendly-appeal commission and validation or quashing of the mise en demeure by the judges. Two further points from those rulings deserve a place in every challenge letter. First, the courts verify the recovery time limits as a genuine guarantee for the insured: the Paris 2023 ruling notes that the limitation rules for recovering contributions, running from the end of the calendar year for which they are due, form the real safeguard of legal certainty and equality before the law, and it checked that they had been respected in the case before it, so the dates on the demand and on the formal notice should always be tested against those limits. Second, paying private health insurance during the disputed period does not convert into a credit against the CSM, as the Paris 2025 ruling shows, so private cover should be bought for protection, not presented afterwards as an offset. Built this way, on the right year, the right status, the right base and the right dates, a challenge gives the judges something to work with, whereas a bare complaint about lateness gives them nothing the statute allows them to sanction.

Conclusion

The British early retiree’s healthcare position in France rests on two pillars that must be handled in order. First, affiliation to PUMA on the inactive-resident track, which demands a lawful residence title, more than three months of proven uninterrupted presence, and a real and permanent home in France, with private insurance covering the waiting period and any year in which presence falls short. Second, the CSM levy that follows about a year later for those who live off capital, calculated at 6.5 per cent on capital income above half the yearly ceiling, reduced where there is professional income, pro-rated for part years, and excluded altogether where a pension, annuity or unemployment benefit is in payment. The statutes set each of these rules in precise terms, the Cour de cassation has confirmed that the three-month condition applies to foreigners without discrimination, and three courts of appeal have shown, in painstaking detail, that late CSM calls survive while wrong figures, wrong status and missed recovery limits do not. A retiree who keeps dated proof of arrival, files a complete CPAM dossier, reads the URSSAF demand against the tax return, and challenges errors through the friendly-appeal commission and then the courts, holds every card the system deals. The cover is there to be claimed, and the bill is there to be checked.

Source : Cour de cassation – Base Open Data « Judilibre » & « Légifrance ».

What our clients say

4,9212 Google reviews
kader ladjouzi
1 month ago

Best real estate law and business law lawyer in Paris. A humane and attentive lawyer, with a wonderful team. Thank you, Maître KOHEN

Translated from French

Janou SAMUEL
2 months ago

Thank you to Maître KOHEN for his analyses of recent case law on fraudulent non-disclosure in property sales. It reassures me about an action for annulment that I am considering after buying a house affected by serious defects intentionally concealed by the seller and not reported by the estate agent; also defects (rising damp) characterised by spreading through-cracks and damp stains, not reported by the estate agent… Worse, defects concealed by the latter or at his instigation, under a coat of paint and by polystyrene tiles glued to the ceiling of a bedroom. And the said estate agent drafted the preliminary contract, which of course contains no information about any of these defects. Just to add that, being 77 years old and suffering from cognitive impairment, I am certain that the estate agent thought I would not be able to discover the deception and above all to establish the fraudulent intent, still less to bring legal proceedings given the complexity and length of the procedure... That is why I am opting for the criminal route, insofar as the intentional concealment of the defects by the seller and then by the estate agent amounts to the fraudulent manoeuvres of art. 313-1 of

Translated from French

Paul MALIK (powlo)
5 months ago

Maître Reda KOHEN assisted me in a dispute concerning a sale agreement with a defaulting party. He provided professional and responsive support, and I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

Rayan Kallout
6 months ago

I highly recommend Maître Reda Kohen. Thanks to his explanations, I was able to recover my security deposit in a situation that seemed blocked. He was responsive, clear, and very professional. A big thank you for his invaluable help!

Translated from French

Naji Jouahri
6 months ago

Excellent support from Maître Kohen in a case combining business law and real estate law. Clear legal analysis from the first meeting, right through to the hearing. Professional and accessible lawyer, I highly recommend his firm in Paris 17.

Translated from French

Halim Tunde
6 months ago

Maître Kohen assisted me in recovering unpaid debts from a defaulting tenant. Procedure mastered from start to finish, from the payment order to eviction. Human, attentive, and always reachable. Thank you for your work.

Translated from French

Cha
6 months ago

As a young student living in an apartment, my landlord tried to make me leave my accommodation even though he had sent me no termination notice. I therefore contacted Mr. Reda Kohen to help me as I couldn’t handle the situation alone. In just 3 days everything was resolved, Maître Kohen defended me and accompanied me with an irreproachable level of commitment and efficiency. I can only recommend his professionalism!

Translated from French

Asmaa Maazaz
7 months ago

I turned to Maître Kohen for a complex real estate dispute and I highly recommend his firm. He is very professional; he thoroughly analyzed my case from the very first appointment and clearly explained the possible options. Thanks to his expertise, we achieved a very favorable outcome. Responsive, a good teacher, and committed, he is a lawyer you can truly trust. Yours faithfully, Miss Maazaz

Translated from French

chaymaa aouadi
8 months ago

I called upon Maître Reda Kohen, a real estate lawyer in Paris, and I am fully satisfied with his support. Very professional, responsive and attentive. He quickly analyzed my case, clearly explained the legal strategy and effectively defended my interests. Thanks to his expertise and determination, we obtained a very favorable outcome. I highly recommend Maître Kohen to anyone looking for a real estate lawyer in Paris.

Translated from French

Fatima Arbouhi
8 months ago

Excellent real estate lawyer. Professional, responsive and attentive, he perfectly met my expectations and accompanied me with great seriousness throughout my case. I highly recommend his services.

Translated from French

Laurent Joulaud
9 months ago

Maître Kohen helped us enormously in our case of eviction of a tenant who hadn't paid rent for many months. He was quick and efficient in drafting the summons and the various actions. He was also very clear about the different stages of the procedure and gave us almost instant feedback when he received documents to communicate. I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

H
9 months ago

The best real estate lawyer in Paris, I recommend without hesitation.

Translated from French

Sokona Dembele
9 months ago

Maître Kohen is an extremely competent and rigorous lawyer. His professionalism, responsiveness, and the quality of his support were remarkable—I weigh my words. Thanks to serious and perfectly mastered work, we obtained a favorable outcome despite a delicate case. He is the best real estate lawyer. I highly recommend him.

Translated from French

Hamid Agouz
1 month ago

I was pleasantly surprised by the responsiveness of Mr Reda Cohen, who took the time to answer my questions about my case instantly. It has become so rare these days to find a lawyer who is so available, responsive and attentive, even when it is simply a matter of answering questions. His answers are clear, precise and reassuring. You can tell that he takes the time to understand the situation and to provide relevant answers. Beyond his excellent ratings on Google, it is above all this availability and this seriousness that make the difference. Many thanks to Mr Reda Cohen for his professionalism and his responsiveness. I highly recommend!

Translated from French

Salon Sisters
1 month ago

Thank you, Maître Kohen, for your professionalism, your responsiveness and your seriousness. You handled my case perfectly, with a great deal of attentiveness, rigour and efficiency. I was very satisfied with your support and the work carried out. I recommend him without hesitation!

Translated from French

Frederic Lopes
1 month ago

Excellent professional. I strongly recommend him for his dedication and expertise.

Translated from French

Mitalie Talie
1 month ago

Great business law lawyer in Paris, attentive, available and understanding. I would come back if I have a problem.

Translated from French

Siko7801 rouger
1 month ago

Thank you for this very humane and professional advice. I strongly recommend.

Translated from French

Coralie Natation
1 month ago

I highly recommend Maître Kohen’s firm for its availability, its responsiveness and its very great professionalism. Thank you for the many pieces of advice and the efficiency of your firm!

Translated from French

Amir
8 months ago

Excellent expertise in real estate law from Me Reda Kohen

Translated from French

Beaudrique Abao
1 month ago
Krep Events Traiteur Breton
1 month ago

very clear article

Translated from French

Zakaria Airbnb
1 month ago
Gabriele
1 month ago